Jump to content

Bharatpedia:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous: Difference between revisions

Bharatpedia:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous (edit)

Revision as of 11:50, 6 December 2023

2,109 bytes added ,  6 December 2023
Add finaltally
(→‎Oppose: too soon.)
(Add finaltally)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<div class="boilerplate rfa" style="background-color:#fff5f5; margin: 2em 0 0 0; padding: 0 10px 0 10px; border: 1px solid #AAAAAA;">
:''The following discussion is preserved as an archive of a [[bharatpedia:requests for adminship|request for adminship]] that '''did not succeed'''. <strong style="color:red">Please do not modify it.</strong>''[[Category:Unsuccessful requests for adminship|{{SUBPAGENAME}}]]
===[[Bharatpedia:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous|Muskit Gergous]]===
===[[Bharatpedia:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous|Muskit Gergous]]===
<span class="plainlinks">[{{fullurl:Bharatpedia:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous|action=edit&section=4}} <b style="color: #002BB8;">Voice your opinion on this candidate</b>]</span> ([[Bharatpedia talk:Requests for adminship/Muskit Gergous|talk page]])
'''Final <span id="rfatally">(0/3/0)</span>; ended 11:49, 6 December 2023 (IST)  [[User:WikiDwarf|WikiDwarf]] ([[User talk:WikiDwarf|talk]]) 11:49, 6 December 2023 (IST)''' <!-- Template:finaltally (automatic) -->
'''{{RfA tally|Muskit Gergous}}<!-- WHEN CLOSING THIS RFA, REPLACE THIS PART WITH {{subst:finaltally|[OPTIONALMESSAGE] OR [result=successful] OR [reason=SNOW] OR [reason=NOTNOW] OR (blank)}} SEE TEMPLATE FOR MORE DETAILS -->; Scheduled to end 17:40, 5 December 2023 (UTC)'''


====Nomination====
====Nomination====
Line 40: Line 42:
=====Oppose=====
=====Oppose=====
# My primary concern is related to Muskit's maturity and level of experience. It appears that Muskit may still be in the early stages of their journey within the Bharatpedia community, and their experience may not be extensive enough to handle the diverse challenges that come with an admin role. Admins play a crucial role in maintaining the integrity and functionality of the platform, and it is essential to ensure that candidates possess the necessary experience to make well-informed decisions.
# My primary concern is related to Muskit's maturity and level of experience. It appears that Muskit may still be in the early stages of their journey within the Bharatpedia community, and their experience may not be extensive enough to handle the diverse challenges that come with an admin role. Admins play a crucial role in maintaining the integrity and functionality of the platform, and it is essential to ensure that candidates possess the necessary experience to make well-informed decisions.
 
#: Additionally, I have observed that Muskit's focus seems to be rather narrow as well as some of his articles denied of lacking proper sources [https://en.bharatpedia.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Muskit_Gergous&action=edit&section=2] , conflict with admin WikiDwarf[https://en.bharatpedia.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Muskit_Gergous&action=edit&section=3]. A well-rounded admin should have a broad understanding of the various facets of the community, and their decisions should reflect consideration for the diverse needs and opinions of its members. If elected, it is crucial that an admin is capable of addressing a wide range of issues and contributing to the platform's growth holistically.
:: Additionally, I have observed that Muskit's focus seems to be rather narrow as well as some of his articles denied of lacking proper sources [https://en.bharatpedia.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Muskit_Gergous&action=edit&section=2] , conflict with admin WikiDwarf[https://en.bharatpedia.org/index.php?title=User_talk:Muskit_Gergous&action=edit&section=3]. A well-rounded admin should have a broad understanding of the various facets of the community, and their decisions should reflect consideration for the diverse needs and opinions of its members. If elected, it is crucial that an admin is capable of addressing a wide range of issues and contributing to the platform's growth holistically.
#: I want to emphasize that my opposition is not a personal attack on Muskit but rather a consideration of the qualifications and attributes necessary for a successful admin. It is important for Bharatpedia to have a team of administrators who collectively possess the skills, experience, and maturity required to lead the community effectively. [[User:Magadha Historian|Magadha Historian]] ([[User talk:Magadha Historian|talk]]) 15:04, 29 November 2023 (IST)
 
:: I want to emphasize that my opposition is not a personal attack on Muskit but rather a consideration of the qualifications and attributes necessary for a successful admin. It is important for Bharatpedia to have a team of administrators who collectively possess the skills, experience, and maturity required to lead the community effectively. [[User:Magadha Historian|Magadha Historian]] ([[User talk:Magadha Historian|talk]]) 15:04, 29 November 2023 (IST)
 
# I agree with Magadha Historian, and I think Muskit Gergous lack the knowledge of policies and guidelines. They recently incorrectly moved some pages and draftified [[Basudeipur]] which is a notable subject under [[Bharatpedia:Notability (geographic features)]] and apart from that they also moved [[Draft:Rohit Gill]] to the main namespace two weeks ago just after the submission was declined by WikiDwarf due to notability and sources so I don't feel they are a good fit for the sysop group. Maybe in future but not at this time, sorry. [[User:Ajay Kumar|Ajay Kumar]] ([[User talk:Ajay Kumar|talk]]) 19:57, 30 November 2023 (IST)
# I agree with Magadha Historian, and I think Muskit Gergous lack the knowledge of policies and guidelines. They recently incorrectly moved some pages and draftified [[Basudeipur]] which is a notable subject under [[Bharatpedia:Notability (geographic features)]] and apart from that they also moved [[Draft:Rohit Gill]] to the main namespace two weeks ago just after the submission was declined by WikiDwarf due to notability and sources so I don't feel they are a good fit for the sysop group. Maybe in future but not at this time, sorry. [[User:Ajay Kumar|Ajay Kumar]] ([[User talk:Ajay Kumar|talk]]) 19:57, 30 November 2023 (IST)
 
#: My purpose of talking is not to offend anyone, I am applying here to become an administrator so that [[Bharatpedia]] can be brought on par with [[Wikipedia]]. [[User:Muskit Gergous|Muskit Gergous]] ([[User talk:Muskit Gergous|talk]]) 9:25, 30 November 2023 (IST)
# As per above. Also, despite knowing the facts that [[Draft:Farhan Rana Rajpoot]] is not ready for the main namespace, Muskit Gergous tried to push the draft to the main namespace multiple times and was involve in move war with an admin. [[User:BellaCH|BellaCH]] ([[User talk:BellaCH|talk]]) 13:00, 3 December 2023 (IST)
<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts.  Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. -->
<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts.  Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. -->


Line 55: Line 55:


=====General comments=====
=====General comments=====
*
* I don't know why but Muskit engaged in a self-vote [https://en.bharatpedia.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/440354], leaving it unsigned vote in the name of admin WikiDwarf. This seems like a childish attempt to deceive Bharatpedians. [[User:Magadha Historian|Magadha Historian]] ([[User talk:Magadha Historian|talk]]) 20:35, 30 November 2023 (IST)
:: Now you are talking about me. My aim is to become an administrator so that [[Bharatpedia]] can be brought on par with [[Wikipedia]] and get it more and more in google search. This is my goal.[[User:Muskit Gergous|Muskit Gergous]] ([[User talk:Muskit Gergous|talk]]) 9:32, 30 November 2023 (IST)
::: I already explained everything . Please read my above comment .[[User:Magadha Historian|Magadha Historian]] ([[User talk:Magadha Historian|talk]]) 23:26, 30 November 2023 (IST)
::::{{re|Muskit Gergous}} You are doing a good job and we respect your dedication but please understand that the adminship is a very sensitive user right and it require a lot of knowledge and understanding of policies and guidelines.


<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts.  Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. -->
<!-- Please do not submit comments before the RfA starts.  Feel free to remove this notice once the RfA has been transcluded. -->
<!-- Place a horizontal rule (----) between separate discussions for organization. -->
<!-- Place a horizontal rule (----) between separate discussions for organization. -->
:''The above adminship discussion is preserved as an archive of the discussion. <span style="color:red">'''Please do not modify it.'''</span> Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page (such as the talk page of either [[{{NAMESPACE}} talk:{{PAGENAME}}|this nomination]] or the nominated user). No further edits should be made to this page.''</div>
Retrieved from "https://en.bharatpedia.org/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/440466...441350"