Review discussion[edit source]
hello thanks ! please check out article again I have recreated the article using sources, guide me wherever needed Shah Syed Muhammad Ali (talk) 23:16, 3 October 2026 (IST)
- Hello, thanks for the update. I have checked the article again. While there is some independent coverage in sources such as The Times of India and Inquilab, the current sources do not yet appear to establish sufficient significant coverage to demonstrate notability. General notability guideline requires significant coverage in reliable, independent secondary sources. A number of the other sources are Internet Archive copies of self-published or affiliated material. Archiving such material does not make the underlying source independent for establishing notability.
- The previous decline by @WikiDwarf was therefore reasonable based on the sourcing available at that time. I also checked the changes since then, but I don't see enough substantial new independent secondary coverage to resolve the notability concern. If additional substantial coverage from independent publications is available, the article can be reassessed based on those sources. Editorial Oversight(Talk with me) 23:42, 3 October 2026 (IST)
- Thank you for taking the time to review the article again. I understand the concern regarding notability and the distinction between independent and affiliated sources.
- However, I would like to point out that Veritas International Express has received significant coverage from independent sources, including The Times of India and Inquilab, which I believe should be considered when assessing the subject’s notability.
- I have also noticed that a number of articles currently in Bharatpedia’s mainspace have limited sourcing or do not yet have sufficiently developed citations, yet they have been allowed to remain in mainspace. In that context, I would like to request that this article also be moved to mainspace, with the understanding that additional reliable and independent sources can be added over time as they become available.
- I am committed to improving the article’s sourcing and would be happy to add further citations and independent coverage as part of that process. I hope the article can therefore be moved to mainspace and allowed an opportunity for further improvement rather than being held back solely on the basis of its current sourcing. Shah Syed Muhammad Ali (talk) 11:57, 4 October 2026 (IST)