Bharatpedia:Arguments to avoid in deletion discussions lists reasoning that carries little or no weight when a page is discussed at Articles for deletion or another deletion venue. Closers weigh arguments that cite policy; the arguments below do not, and using them weakens an otherwise good case.

Arguments about the subject[edit source]

  • "It is notable because it exists": existence is not notability. Notability needs significant coverage in reliable, independent sources.
  • "Just search the web": if sources exist, link to them. A closer cannot credit sources nobody has shown.
  • "Everyone knows it": fame claimed without sources is not verifiable. See Verifiability.
  • "It is useful / interesting / I like it": personal value is not a policy reason, for keeping or for deleting.

Arguments about the article[edit source]

  • "The article is badly written, so delete it": poor writing is a reason to improve or tag an article, not to delete it, when the subject is notable.
  • "It is a stub": short articles on notable subjects are welcome and can grow.
  • "Nobody has improved it": lack of attention is not a deletion criterion.

Arguments about other pages[edit source]

  • "Other similar articles exist": each article is judged on its own merits. A similar article may simply not have been nominated yet.
  • "This other article was deleted, so delete this too": past outcomes guide, but do not bind, a new discussion. See Precedents.

Arguments about the process[edit source]

  • Counting votes: deletion discussions are decided by consensus and the strength of arguments, not by a headcount.
  • Attacking the nominator or other editors: discuss the article, not the person. See Civility.
  • "Delete it and it can be recreated later": if the subject is notable now, the article should be kept and improved now.

See also[edit source]