Contested deletion[edit source]
Overview and Verdict=[edit source]
This draft is a mixture of genuine historical facts and an elaborate genealogical hoax.
The subject, Mohini Mohan Dhar, was a real historical figure—an educator, administrator, State Judge, Dewan of Mayurbhanj State, and Theosophical author. However, the article has been heavily adulterated with claims connecting him to a fictional royal dynasty called the "House of Dar" (or "Dar Raj"). This hoax appears across several user-edited wiki mirrors and self-published blogs, accompanied by fabricated titles, non-existent books, and forged citations.
---
Detailed Fact-Check Breakdown=[edit source]
1. What is TRUE (Historically Verified)[edit source]
- Dewan and Judge of Mayurbhanj:
Mohini Mohan Dhar (M.A., B.L.) was indeed a private tutor to the young Maharaja Sriram Chandra Bhanj Deo at Ravenshaw College in Cuttack. When the Maharaja assumed control of Mayurbhanj State, he appointed Dhar to senior positions, including Legal Adviser, State Judge, Vice-President of the State Council, and Dewan of Mayurbhanj (serving until 1912).
- Tata Steel Lease & Railway Link:
Following geologist P.N. Bose’s surveys of iron ore in the Gorumahisani hills, Dhar, acting as the Maharaja’s Dewan and counsellor, played a central role in formalizing the 1905 mining lease with Jamsetji Tata/TISCO and supporting the extension of the narrow-gauge light railway connecting Rupsa, Baripada, and the mining belts.
- Assassination Attempt (1909):
State records from Mayurbhanj confirm that Dhar survived an assassination attempt by an aggrieved former official while riding in his carriage in 1909.
- Theosophy and Publications:
Dhar was an active member of the Theosophical Society. Following the death of the Maharaja in 1912, he traveled to the UK, where he associated with the Westminster Lodge and published two genuine books in 1919: * *Krishna the Charioteer: Or the Teachings of Bhagavad Gita* * *Gauranga and His Gospel*
- Family Members:
* His son Satyendra Mohan Dhar was indeed a member of the elite Indian Civil Service (ICS) and received the Order of the Indian Empire (CIE). * His son Dhirendra Mohan Dhar was admitted to the Bar at Gray's Inn. * His grandson Manojit Mohan Dhar was a noted chemist and Director of the Central Drug Research Institute (CDRI).
---
2. What is FABRICATED (The "House of Dar" Hoax)[edit source]
- Royal Titles ("Maharaja", "King", "Raja IV"):
* Dhar was never a "King" or a "Maharaja." * There was no princely state, royal dynasty, or sovereign lineage called the "House of Dar" or "Dar Raj". * His ancestors were not monarchs styled "Raja III Rai Bahadur Hara Mohan Dhar" or "Maharaja Virendra Mohan Dar." The titles "Maharaja IV", "Rani Elokeshi", and "Maharani Saudamini" are completely fabricated.
- Commemorative Mayurbhanj Gold Coin:
The claim that the Maharaja of Mayurbhanj struck a ceremonial gold coin in 1906 honoring "Raja Virendra Mohan Dar" and displayed it at the "Dar Raj Kachahri" is an invention unsupported by numismatic or archival records.
- Fabricated Sources and Citations:
* The citation *“Jitendranath Ghose (1931), The Raja of Dar - Life and Legacy of Virendra Vasudev of Dar, Bridgebit Printing Works”* is a fictitious citation designed to validate the hoax. * The citation *“Pal, Gurnindra (1908), রাজা বীরেন্দ্র মোহন দার এর জীবনচরিত্র [Raja Virendra Mohan Dar's Biography]”* is likewise fictitious.
---
3. What is DUBIOUS or MISATTRIBUTED[edit source]
- Dhar Brothers of Calcutta:
While *Dhar Brothers* was a real vintage stationery/fountain pen business in Calcutta (known for importing pens and producing the "Ruby" safety pen), attributing its ownership to Mohini Mohan Dhar and claiming it was founded by a royal "Raja Hara Mohan Dhar" appears to stem from unverified pen-enthusiast blogs conflating distinct families or accepting self-submitted biographical claims.
- "Dhar Zamindar Palace" and Schools:
The Dhar family held ancestral land (zamindari) in Jalsin (Dhamrai, Dhaka, present-day Bangladesh), and Elokeshi High School in Jalsin does exist. However, framing it as the "Palace of the House of Dar" or claiming he ruled "19 estates" as a royal sovereign is a gross exaggeration.
---
Summary Recommendation for Wikipedia[edit source]
If publishing this article on Wikipedia: 1. Strip all royal terminology: Remove references to the "House of Dar", "Maharaja IV", "Raja", "Dar Raj", "Maharani", and royal succession.
2. Reframe the Infobox: Use `
Mohini Mohan Dhar |
|---|
` or `
Mohini Mohan Dhar |
|---|
` rather than `
| Mohini Mohan Dhar |
|---|
`.
3. Focus on his real historical legacy: Tutor to the Maharaja of Mayurbhanj, State Judge, Dewan of Mayurbhanj (1905–1912), his involvement in the Tata Steel lease negotiations, and his genuine Theosophical/philosophical writings. 4. Purge fabricated citations: Remove all references to pseudo-historical texts about "Virendra Mohan Dar.”