Bharatpedia:Articles for deletion/Precedents explains how the outcomes of past deletion discussions guide later ones.

What a precedent is[edit source]

When similar articles are nominated again and again, for example schools, local politicians, small businesses or villages, the community's past decisions form a pattern. That pattern is a precedent: a new discussion on the same kind of subject usually reaches the same outcome, unless the article in front of it is clearly stronger or weaker than the earlier ones.

How precedents are used[edit source]

  • A precedent is a guide, not a rule. Every discussion is decided on the article and the sources presented in it.
  • When citing a precedent, link to the earlier discussion and say briefly why the two cases are alike.
  • A single past discussion is weak evidence. A long run of consistent outcomes is strong evidence.
  • Precedents never override policy. Notability, Verifiability and the subject-specific guidelines decide first.

Recording precedents[edit source]

As deletion discussions close, outcomes that repeat for a class of subjects can be summarised here under a heading for that class, with links to two or three representative discussions. Add a precedent only when the pattern is clear, and note any important exception, such as a subject-specific guideline that sets a different test.

See also[edit source]