The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

Bharatpedia:Mass nomination is an essay about nominating many pages for deletion in a single discussion.

When a group nomination is fair

A group nomination is reasonable when the pages genuinely stand or fall together, for example:

  • a set of articles created in one batch with the same problem, such as the same missing sources;
  • a series of near-identical stubs about the same class of subject, where one discussion can settle the pattern;
  • pages copied from the same source in a copyright problem.

When it is not fair

  • The pages have different strengths. A strong article bundled with weak ones may be deleted without its own hearing.
  • The nominator has not checked each page individually. Every nominated page must be looked at, not just listed.
  • The bundle is so large that participants cannot reasonably review it.

Good practice

  • Tag every nominated page with the deletion notice, and notify the creators where practical.
  • State the shared reason once, clearly, and note any page in the group that differs.
  • If discussion shows the pages differ, split the nomination and let the unlike pages be discussed separately.
  • Closers may keep, delete or split a group nomination in part.

See also