The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

Bharatpedia:Deletion reform is an information page about proposals to change how deletion works on Bharatpedia.

Why reform comes up

Deletion is the project's most contested process. Editors regularly raise the same concerns: discussions that attract too few participants, new articles nominated within minutes of creation, borderline subjects decided inconsistently, and creators who leave after a first article is deleted.

Common reform ideas

  • Draft first: move weak new articles to draft space for improvement instead of deleting them, and delete only if nobody improves them within a set period.
  • Longer or shorter discussions: change the standard seven-day discussion period so more, or fewer, discussions reach a clear result.
  • Clearer subject tests: write or sharpen subject-specific notability guidelines so outcomes depend less on who happens to comment.
  • Better notification: make sure article creators and main contributors are always told about a nomination and have time to respond.
  • Faster speedy deletion: widen or narrow the speedy deletion criteria so obvious cases need no discussion at all.

How to propose a change

Deletion is governed by the deletion policy and the deletion process. Changes to either need community agreement: raise the proposal at the Village pump proposals section, explain the problem it solves, and show examples. A change that wins consensus there is then written into the policy or process page.

See also