Bharatpedia:Deletion reform is an information page about proposals to change how deletion works on Bharatpedia.

Why reform comes up[edit source]

Deletion is the project's most contested process. Editors regularly raise the same concerns: discussions that attract too few participants, new articles nominated within minutes of creation, borderline subjects decided inconsistently, and creators who leave after a first article is deleted.

Common reform ideas[edit source]

  • Draft first: move weak new articles to draft space for improvement instead of deleting them, and delete only if nobody improves them within a set period.
  • Longer or shorter discussions: change the standard seven-day discussion period so more, or fewer, discussions reach a clear result.
  • Clearer subject tests: write or sharpen subject-specific notability guidelines so outcomes depend less on who happens to comment.
  • Better notification: make sure article creators and main contributors are always told about a nomination and have time to respond.
  • Faster speedy deletion: widen or narrow the speedy deletion criteria so obvious cases need no discussion at all.

How to propose a change[edit source]

Deletion is governed by the deletion policy and the deletion process. Changes to either need community agreement: raise the proposal at the Village pump proposals section, explain the problem it solves, and show examples. A change that wins consensus there is then written into the policy or process page.

See also[edit source]