Bharatpedia:Relist bias is an essay about a weakness in the relisting system: a discussion that is relisted again and again does not stay neutral.

How the bias works[edit source]

When a discussion is relisted, the editors who already commented usually do not return, and a fresh group of editors sees the page. If a closer relists only when the early comments point one way, for example towards keeping, and closes promptly when they point the other way, the process quietly favours deletion: keep-leaning discussions get more chances to flip than delete-leaning ones. The same bias can run in reverse.

Relisting also changes who participates. Editors with more time and stronger views are more likely to comment in a relisted discussion, so a second or third round is not a fresh sample of the community.

Avoiding the bias[edit source]

  • Relist because the discussion genuinely needs more input, never because the current direction is unwelcome.
  • Follow the limit in the deletion process: at most two relists, and a third only with a clear explanation.
  • If a discussion has enough policy-based argument, close it, even if the outcome is not the one you would have chosen.
  • A "no consensus" close is a valid result. It is better than relisting until the desired answer appears.

See also[edit source]