Bharatpedia:Deletion and deletionism explains two opposite instincts about what Bharatpedia should contain, and why the project follows neither extreme.
The two instincts[edit source]
Deletionism is the view that Bharatpedia is better with fewer, stronger articles: anything doubtful should be removed, because weak articles harm credibility and are hard to maintain.
Inclusionism is the opposite view: Bharatpedia should keep almost everything that is verifiable, because storage is cheap, readers differ in what they need, and a small article can grow.
Where Bharatpedia stands[edit source]
Bharatpedia follows its written rules, not either instinct:
- A subject that meets the notability guideline and can be verified from reliable sources belongs here, even if the current article is short or rough.
- A subject that fails those tests is removed, even if the article is long and well written.
- Borderline cases are settled by consensus in a deletion discussion, weighing the arguments made, not the labels editors give each other.
Calling another editor a "deletionist" or an "inclusionist" is not an argument. In a discussion, cite the policy that applies to the page in front of you.