The printable version is no longer supported and may have rendering errors. Please update your browser bookmarks and please use the default browser print function instead.

Bharatpedia:Overcategorization is an essay about adding too many, or too narrow, categories to an article.

The problem

Categories exist so readers can browse from one article to related ones. A category helps only if it groups a real set of articles by a defining characteristic of their subjects. When every passing detail of an article becomes a category, the system fills with tiny, overlapping categories that nobody browses and nobody maintains.

Signs of overcategorization

  • A category that applies to nearly every article, or to only one or two.
  • Categories for characteristics the article mentions but that do not define the subject, such as a person's hobbies or a town's single famous visitor.
  • Several near-duplicate categories differing only in wording.
  • Categories that sort by opinion, such as "important" or "controversial" subjects.

Good practice

  • Categorize by what the subject is, not by everything the article says about it.
  • Prefer an existing broader category to creating a narrow new one.
  • If a category has no clear inclusion test that another editor could apply the same way, it is probably too narrow.

See also