Proposed merge of Narendra Modi and the Dawoodi Bohra community into Dawoodi Bohra[edit source]
A community endorsement by a politician doesn't deserve a separate page. Dokania😎(📩) 21:30, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Oppose : article has enough sourced content to remain as standalone. 🍁Bharatwiki Socrates🍁(📩) 22:55, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Are you sure about that? It will open the door to multiple standalone articles like these. E.g, Modi and the congress party, Rahul Gandhi and RSS. anything like this. I think this kind of topics can be covered in the main article itself. Dokania😎(📩) 23:37, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Any notable topic that has received significant coverage in reliable sources deserves its own article. 🍁Bharatwiki Socrates🍁(📩) 23:42, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- I don't think it's encyclopaedic at all. It will make Bharatpedia like an essay site where it has essay on different topics. While I accept some topics in politics (like 2022 Narendra Modi security breach ) may warrant a standalone article. This seems not to be the case here. I would request @WikiDwarf to intervene here. I believe this it lowers the quality of Bharatpedia and paves path for making it lesser and lesser encyclopaedic. Bharatpedia:NOTEVERYTHING Dokania😎(📩) 23:51, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Any notable topic that has received significant coverage in reliable sources deserves its own article. 🍁Bharatwiki Socrates🍁(📩) 23:42, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Are you sure about that? It will open the door to multiple standalone articles like these. E.g, Modi and the congress party, Rahul Gandhi and RSS. anything like this. I think this kind of topics can be covered in the main article itself. Dokania😎(📩) 23:37, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Oppose – Religious or political topics are not automatically unsuitable for standalone articles. Any topic can have its own article if it meets GNG and has sufficient coverage in reliable, independent sources. The decision should be based on notability, not the subject's category. Editorial Oversight(Talk with me) 23:06, 17 November 2026 (IST)
- Oppose – The topic has sufficient independent coverage to merit a standalone article. Merge decisions should be based on notability and reliable sources, not hypothetical comparisons. ButterflyCat (talk) 16:24, 18 November 2026 (IST)
- I have neither challenged the notability nor the lack of sources. I have just challenged it being encyclopaedic. Dokania😎(📩) 17:32, 18 November 2026 (IST)
- I think you may not yet be fully familiar with the encyclopaedic guidelines and their application in this context. Wikipedia follows stricter notability standards, but I don't believe we should automatically apply the same threshold to every Bharatpedia discussion. The attached sources are original, independent publications produced by journalists, so I don't see a valid reason to merge the article unnecessarily.You suggested that the same information could be added to the main Dawoodi Bohra article, but I believe this is a separate topic with its own scope and subject matter. It deserves independent coverage and a standalone article. I fully support retaining it as a separate article. ButterflyCat (talk) 17:39, 18 November 2026 (IST)
- I have neither challenged the notability nor the lack of sources. I have just challenged it being encyclopaedic. Dokania😎(📩) 17:32, 18 November 2026 (IST)
- Oppose : article has enough sourced content to remain as standalone. 🍁Bharatwiki Socrates🍁(📩) 22:55, 17 November 2026 (IST)