Jump to content

Raga: Difference between revisions

885 bytes removed ,  16 June 2022
no edit summary
imported>ClueBot NG
m (Reverting possible vandalism by 2409:4062:193:9D89:FD92:9D3:C656:905F to version by Kailash29792. Report False Positive? Thanks, ClueBot NG. (4026222) (Bot))
 
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Short description|Melodic mode in Indian music}}
{{Short description|Melodic mode in Indian music}}
{{About|melodic modes in the music of the Indian subcontinent|subgenre of reggae music|Ragga|similar terms|Raga (disambiguation)|and|Ragam (disambiguation)}}
{{About||other uses|Raga (disambiguation)|and|Ragam (disambiguation)|and|Ragas (fly)|the subgenre of reggae music|Ragga}}
{{Redirect|ragas|the genus of insects|Ragas (genus)}}
{{Italic title}}
{{Italic title}}
{{Indian classical music}}
{{Indian classical music}}
[[File:Melakarta.katapayadi.sankhya.72 correction for no 41-47-53-59-65-71 da2-instead-of-da3.png|alt=|thumb|Melakarta Ragas]]
[[File:Melakarta.katapayadi.sankhya.72 correction for no 41-47-53-59-65-71 da2-instead-of-da3.png|alt=|thumb|Melakarta Ragas of [[Carnatic music|Carnatic Music]] ]]
A '''''raga''''' or '''''raag''''' ([[IAST]]: rāga; also '''''raaga''''' or '''''ragam'''''; literally "coloring, tingeing, dyeing"{{Sfn|Titon et al.|2008|p=284}}{{Sfn|Wilke | Moebus|  2011| pp=222 with footnote 463}}) is a melodic framework for improvisation akin to a [[musical mode|melodic mode]] in [[Indian classical music]].{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}} The ''rāga'' is a unique and central feature of the classical Indian music tradition, and as a result has no direct translation to concepts in [[classical European music]].{{Sfn|Kaufmann|1968|p=v}}{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=65–67}} Each ''rāga'' is an array of melodic structures with musical motifs, considered in the Indian tradition to have the ability to "colour the mind" and affect the emotions of the audience.{{Sfn|Titon et al.|2008|p=284}}{{Sfn|Wilke | Moebus|2011| pp=222 with footnote 463}}{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=65–67}}
A '''''raga''''' or '''''raag''''' ({{IAST3|rāga}}; also '''''raaga''''' or '''''ragam'''''; literally 'coloring', 'tingeing', 'dyeing'{{Sfn|Titon et al.|2008|p=284}}{{Sfn|Wilke | Moebus|  2011| pp=222 with footnote 463}}) is a melodic framework for improvisation akin to a [[musical mode|melodic mode]] in [[Indian classical music]].{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}} The ''rāga'' is a unique and central feature of the classical Indian music tradition, and as a result has no direct translation to concepts in [[classical European music]].{{Sfn|Kaufmann|1968|p=v}}{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=65–67}} Each ''rāga'' is an array of melodic structures with musical motifs, considered in the Indian tradition to have the ability to "colour the mind" and affect the emotions of the audience.{{Sfn|Titon et al.|2008|p=284}}{{Sfn|Wilke | Moebus|2011| pp=222 with footnote 463}}{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=65–67}}


Each ''rāga'' provides the musician with a musical framework within which to improvise.{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}}{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–174}}{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} Improvisation by the musician involves creating sequences of notes allowed by the ''rāga'' in keeping with rules specific to the ''rāga''. ''Rāga''s range from small ''rāga''s like [[Bahar (raga)|Bahar]] and [[Shahana]] that are not much more than songs to big ''rāga''s like [[Malkauns]], [[Darbari]] and [[Yaman (raga)|Yaman]], which have great scope for improvisation and for which performances can last over an hour. ''Rāga''s may change over time, with an example being [[Marwa (raga)|Marwa]], the primary development of which has been going down into the lower octave, in contrast with the traditional middle octave.{{sfn|Raja|unknown|p=unknown, Quote: "Due to the influence of [[Amir Khan (singer)|Amir Khan]]"}} Each ''rāga'' traditionally has an emotional significance and symbolic associations such as with season, time and mood.{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}} The ''rāga'' is considered a means in the Indian musical tradition to evoking specific feelings in an audience. Hundreds of ''rāga'' are recognized in the classical tradition, of which about 30 are common,{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}}{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} and each ''rāga'' has its "own unique melodic personality".{{Sfn|Hast|James R. Cowdery|Stanley Arnold Scott|1999|p=137}}
Each ''rāga'' provides the musician with a musical framework within which to improvise.{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}}{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–174}}{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} Improvisation by the musician involves creating sequences of notes allowed by the ''rāga'' in keeping with rules specific to the ''rāga''. ''Rāga''s range from small ''rāga''s like [[Bahar (raga)|Bahar]] and [[Shahana]] that are not much more than songs to big ''rāga''s like [[Malkauns]], [[Darbari]] and [[Yaman (raga)|Yaman]], which have great scope for improvisation and for which performances can last over an hour. ''Rāga''s may change over time, with an example being [[Marwa (raga)|Marwa]], the primary development of which has been going down into the lower octave, in contrast with the traditional middle octave.{{sfn|Raja|unknown|p=unknown, Quote: "Due to the influence of [[Amir Khan (singer)|Amir Khan]]"}} Each ''rāga'' traditionally has an emotional significance and symbolic associations such as with season, time and mood.{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}} The ''rāga'' is considered a means in the Indian musical tradition to evoking specific feelings in an audience. Hundreds of ''rāga'' are recognized in the classical tradition, of which about 30 are common,{{Sfn|Lochtefeld|2002|p=545}}{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} and each ''rāga'' has its "own unique melodic personality".{{Sfn|Hast|James R. Cowdery|Stanley Arnold Scott|1999|p=137}}
Line 11: Line 10:
There are two main classical music traditions, ''[[Hindustani classical music|Hindustani]]'' (North Indian) and ''[[Carnatic classical music|Carnatic]]'' (South Indian), and the concept of ''rāga'' is shared by both.{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–174}} ''Rāga'' are also found in Sikh traditions such as in ''[[Guru Granth Sahib]]'', the primary scripture of [[Sikhism]].{{Sfn|Kapoor|2005|pp=46–52}} Similarly, it is a part of the ''[[qawwali]]'' tradition in [[Sufism|Sufi]] Islamic communities of [[South Asia]].{{Sfn|Salhi|2013|pp=183–84}} Some popular [[Filmi|Indian film songs]] and [[ghazal]]s use ''rāgas'' in their composition.{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=107–108}}
There are two main classical music traditions, ''[[Hindustani classical music|Hindustani]]'' (North Indian) and ''[[Carnatic classical music|Carnatic]]'' (South Indian), and the concept of ''rāga'' is shared by both.{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–174}} ''Rāga'' are also found in Sikh traditions such as in ''[[Guru Granth Sahib]]'', the primary scripture of [[Sikhism]].{{Sfn|Kapoor|2005|pp=46–52}} Similarly, it is a part of the ''[[qawwali]]'' tradition in [[Sufism|Sufi]] Islamic communities of [[South Asia]].{{Sfn|Salhi|2013|pp=183–84}} Some popular [[Filmi|Indian film songs]] and [[ghazal]]s use ''rāgas'' in their composition.{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=107–108}}


Every raga has a [[Svara|swara]] (a note or named pitch) called [[shadja]], or adhara sadja, whose pitch may be chosen arbitrarily by the performer. This is taken to mark the beginning and end of the ''[[saptak]]'' (loosely, octave). The raga also contains an adhista, which is either the swara [[Madhyama (music)|Ma]] or the swara [[Panchama|Pa]]. The adhista divides the octave into two parts or ''anga'' - the ''purvanga'', which contains lower notes, and the ''uttaranga'', which contains higher notes. Every raga has a ''[[Vadi (music)|vadi]]'' and a ''[[Samavadi|samvadi]]''. The ''vadi'' is the most prominent swara, which means that an improvising musician emphasizes or pays more attention to the ''vadi'' than to other notes. The samvadi is consonant with the vadi (always from the ''anga'' that does not contain the vadi) and is the second most prominent swara in the raga.{{clarify|date=May 2021}}
Every raga has a [[Svara|swara]] (a note or named pitch) called [[shadja]], or adhara sadja, whose pitch may be chosen arbitrarily by the performer. This is taken to mark the beginning and end of the ''[[saptak]]'' (loosely, octave). The raga also contains an adhista, which is either the swara [[Madhyama (music)|Ma]] or the swara [[Panchama|Pa]]. The adhista divides the octave into two parts or ''anga'' the ''purvanga'', which contains lower notes, and the ''uttaranga'', which contains higher notes. Every raga has a ''[[Vadi (music)|vadi]]'' and a ''[[Samavadi|samvadi]]''. The ''vadi'' is the most prominent swara, which means that an improvising musician emphasizes or pays more attention to the ''vadi'' than to other notes. The samvadi is consonant with the vadi (always from the ''anga'' that does not contain the vadi) and is the second most prominent swara in the raga.{{clarify|date=May 2021}}


==Terminology==
==Terminology==
The Sanskrit word ''rāga'' (Sanskrit: [[wikt:राग|राग]]) has Indian roots, as ''*reg-'' which connotes "to dye". It is found in Greek, Persian, Khwarezmian and other languages, in variants such as "raxt", "rang", "rakt" and others. The words "red" and "rado" are also related.<ref>{{cite book|author=Douglas Q. Adams|title=Encyclopedia of Indo-European Culture|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=tzU3RIV2BWIC&pg=PA572|year=1997|publisher=Routledge|isbn=978-1-884964-98-5|pages=572–573}}</ref> According to [[Monier Monier-Williams]], the term comes from a Sanskrit word for "the act of colouring or dyeing", or simply a "colour, hue, tint, dye".{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}} The term also connotes an emotional state referring to a "feeling, affection, desire, interest, joy or delight", particularly related to passion, love, or sympathy for a subject or something.<ref name="journal2">{{cite journal|last1=Mathur|first1=Avantika |last2=Vijayakumar| first2=Suhas |last3=Chakravarti|first3=Bhismadev |last4=Singh|first4=Nandini| title=Emotional responses to Hindustani raga music: the role of musical structure|journal=Frontiers in Psychology|volume=6 |year=2015|page=513 |doi=10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00513|pmid=25983702 |pmc=4415143 |doi-access=free}}</ref> In the context of ancient Indian music, the term refers to a harmonious note, melody, formula, building block of music available to a musician to construct a state of experience in the audience.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}}
The Sanskrit word ''rāga'' (Sanskrit: [[wikt:राग|राग]]) has Indian roots, as ''*reg-'' which connotes "to dye". Cognates are found in Greek, Persian, Khwarezmian and other languages, such as "raxt", "rang", "rakt" and others. The words "red" and "rado" are also related.<ref>{{cite book|author=Douglas Q. Adams|title=Encyclopedia of Indo-European Culture|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=tzU3RIV2BWIC&pg=PA572|year=1997|publisher=Routledge|isbn=978-1-884964-98-5|pages=572–573}}</ref> According to [[Monier Monier-Williams]], the term comes from a Sanskrit word for "the act of colouring or dyeing", or simply a "colour, hue, tint, dye".{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}} The term also connotes an emotional state referring to a "feeling, affection, desire, interest, joy or delight", particularly related to passion, love, or sympathy for a subject or something.<ref name="journal2">{{cite journal|last1=Mathur|first1=Avantika |last2=Vijayakumar| first2=Suhas |last3=Chakravarti|first3=Bhismadev |last4=Singh|first4=Nandini| title=Emotional responses to Hindustani raga music: the role of musical structure|journal=Frontiers in Psychology|volume=6 |year=2015|page=513 |doi=10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00513|pmid=25983702 |pmc=4415143 |doi-access=free}}</ref> In the context of ancient Indian music, the term refers to a harmonious note, melody, formula, building block of music available to a musician to construct a state of experience in the audience.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}}


The word appears in the ancient [[Principal Upanishads]] of [[Hinduism]], as well as the ''[[Bhagavad Gita]]''.<ref name=jacobraga/> For example, verse 3.5 of the ''[[Maitri Upanishad]]'' and verse 2.2.9 of the ''[[Mundaka Upanishad]]'' contain the word ''rāga''. The ''Mundaka Upanishad'' uses it in its discussion of soul (Atman-Brahman) and matter (Prakriti), with the sense that the soul does not "color, dye, stain, tint" the matter.<ref>[https://archive.org/stream/thirteenprincipa028442mbp#page/n393/mode/2up Mundaka Upanishad], Robert Hume, Oxford University Press, page 373</ref> The ''Maitri Upanishad'' uses the term in the sense of "passion, inner quality, psychological state".<ref name=jacobraga>[https://archive.org/stream/UpanishadVakyaKosha-AConcordanceOfThePrincipalUpanishadsAndBhagavad/UpanishadVakyaKoshaSktEng#page/n793/mode/2up A Concordance to the Principal Upanishads and Bhagavadgita], GA Jacob, Motilal Banarsidass, page 787</ref><ref>[https://archive.org/stream/upanishads02ml#page/298/mode/2up Maitri Upanishad], Max Muller, Oxford University Press, page 299</ref> The term ''rāga'' is also found in ancient texts of [[Buddhism]] where it connotes "passion, sensuality, lust, desire" for pleasurable experiences as one of three [[Raga (Buddhism)|impurities]] of a character.<ref name=buswelllopezraga/><ref name=rhysd203/> Alternatively, ''rāga'' is used in Buddhist texts in the sense of "color, dye, hue".<ref name=buswelllopezraga>{{cite book|author1=Robert E. Buswell Jr.|author2=Donald S. Lopez Jr.|title=The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=DXN2AAAAQBAJ |year=2013|publisher=Princeton University Press |isbn=978-1-4008-4805-8 |pages=59, 68, 589}}</ref><ref name=rhysd203>{{cite book|author1=Thomas William Rhys Davids |author2=William Stede |title=Pali-English Dictionary |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0Guw2CnxiucC&pg=PA362 |year=1921|publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |isbn=978-81-208-1144-7|pages= 203, 214, 567–568, 634}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Damien Keown |title=A Dictionary of Buddhism |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=985a1M7L1NcC|year=2004|publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0-19-157917-2|pages=8, 47, 143}}</ref>
The word appears in the ancient [[Principal Upanishads]] of [[Hinduism]], as well as the ''[[Bhagavad Gita]]''.<ref name=jacobraga/> For example, verse 3.5 of the ''[[Maitri Upanishad]]'' and verse 2.2.9 of the ''[[Mundaka Upanishad]]'' contain the word ''rāga''. The ''Mundaka Upanishad'' uses it in its discussion of soul (Atman-Brahman) and matter (Prakriti), with the sense that the soul does not "color, dye, stain, tint" the matter.<ref>[https://archive.org/stream/thirteenprincipa028442mbp#page/n393/mode/2up Mundaka Upanishad], Robert Hume, Oxford University Press, page 373</ref> The ''Maitri Upanishad'' uses the term in the sense of "passion, inner quality, psychological state".<ref name=jacobraga>[https://archive.org/stream/UpanishadVakyaKosha-AConcordanceOfThePrincipalUpanishadsAndBhagavad/UpanishadVakyaKoshaSktEng#page/n793/mode/2up A Concordance to the Principal Upanishads and Bhagavadgita], GA Jacob, Motilal Banarsidass, page 787</ref><ref>[https://archive.org/stream/upanishads02ml#page/298/mode/2up Maitri Upanishad], Max Muller, Oxford University Press, page 299</ref> The term ''rāga'' is also found in ancient texts of [[Buddhism]] where it connotes "passion, sensuality, lust, desire" for pleasurable experiences as one of three [[Raga (Buddhism)|impurities]] of a character.<ref name=buswelllopezraga/><ref name=rhysd203/> Alternatively, ''rāga'' is used in Buddhist texts in the sense of "color, dye, hue".<ref name=buswelllopezraga>{{cite book|author1=Robert E. Buswell Jr.|author2=Donald S. Lopez Jr.|title=The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=DXN2AAAAQBAJ |year=2013|publisher=Princeton University Press |isbn=978-1-4008-4805-8 |pages=59, 68, 589}}</ref><ref name=rhysd203>{{cite book|author1=Thomas William Rhys Davids |author2=William Stede |title=Pali-English Dictionary |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0Guw2CnxiucC&pg=PA362 |year=1921|publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |isbn=978-81-208-1144-7|pages= 203, 214, 567–568, 634}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Damien Keown |title=A Dictionary of Buddhism |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=985a1M7L1NcC|year=2004|publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0-19-157917-2|pages=8, 47, 143}}</ref>
Line 22: Line 21:
The term ''rāga'' in the modern connotation of a melodic format occurs in the ''[[Brihaddeshi]]'' by [[Matanga Muni|Mataṅga Muni]] dated ca. 8th century,{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=3}} or possibly 9th century.{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} The ''Brihaddeshi'' describes ''rāga'' as "a combination of tones which, with beautiful illuminating graces, pleases the people in general".{{sfn|Kaufmann|1968|p=41}}
The term ''rāga'' in the modern connotation of a melodic format occurs in the ''[[Brihaddeshi]]'' by [[Matanga Muni|Mataṅga Muni]] dated ca. 8th century,{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=3}} or possibly 9th century.{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} The ''Brihaddeshi'' describes ''rāga'' as "a combination of tones which, with beautiful illuminating graces, pleases the people in general".{{sfn|Kaufmann|1968|p=41}}


According to [[Emmie te Nijenhuis]], a professor in Indian musicology, the ''Dattilam'' section of ''Brihaddeshi'' has survived into the modern times, but the details of ancient music scholars mentioned in the extant text suggest a more established tradition by the time this text was composed.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=3}} The same essential idea and prototypical framework is found in ancient [[Hinduism|Hindu]] texts, such as the ''Naradiyasiksa'' and the classic Sanskrit work ''[[Natya Shastra]]'' by [[Bharata Muni]], whose chronology has been estimated to sometime between 500 BC and 500 AD,{{Sfn|Dace|1963|p=249}} probably between 200 BC and 200 AD.{{Sfn|Lidova|2014}}
According to [[Emmie te Nijenhuis]], a professor in Indian musicology, the ''Dattilam'' section of ''Brihaddeshi'' has survived into the modern times, but the details of ancient music scholars mentioned in the extant text suggest a more established tradition by the time this text was composed.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=3}} The same essential idea and prototypical framework is found in ancient [[Hinduism|Hindu]] texts, such as the ''Naradiyasiksa'' and the classic Sanskrit work ''[[Natya Shastra]]'' by [[Bharata Muni]], whose chronology has been estimated to sometime between 500 BCE and 500 CE,{{Sfn|Dace|1963|p=249}} probably between 200 BCE and 200 CE.{{Sfn|Lidova|2014}}


Bharata describes a series of empirical experiments he did with the ''[[Veena]]'', then compared what he heard, noting the relationship of fifth intervals as a function of intentionally induced change to the instrument's tuning. Bharata states that certain combination of notes are pleasant, certain not so. His methods of experimenting with the instrument triggered further work by ancient Indian scholars, leading to the development of successive permutations, as well as theories of musical note inter-relationships, interlocking scales and how this makes the listener feel.{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} Bharata discusses ''Bhairava'', ''Kaushika'', ''Hindola'', ''Dipaka'', ''SrI-rāga'', and ''Megha''. Bharata states that these have the ability to trigger a certain affection and the ability to "color the emotional state" in the audience.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}}{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} His encyclopedic ''Natya Shastra'' links his studies on music to the performance arts, and it has been influential in Indian performance arts tradition.{{Sfn|Lal|2004|pp=311–312}}{{Sfn|Kane|1971|pp=30–39}}
Bharata describes a series of empirical experiments he did with the ''[[Veena]]'', then compared what he heard, noting the relationship of fifth intervals as a function of intentionally induced change to the instrument's tuning. Bharata states that certain combination of notes are pleasant, certain not so. His methods of experimenting with the instrument triggered further work by ancient Indian scholars, leading to the development of successive permutations, as well as theories of musical note inter-relationships, interlocking scales and how this makes the listener feel.{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} Bharata discusses ''Bhairava'', ''Kaushika'', ''Hindola'', ''Dipaka'', ''SrI-rāga'', and ''Megha''. Bharata states that these have the ability to trigger a certain affection and the ability to "color the emotional state" in the audience.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899|p=872}}{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=73–74}} His encyclopedic ''Natya Shastra'' links his studies on music to the performance arts, and it has been influential in Indian performance arts tradition.{{Sfn|Lal|2004|pp=311–312}}{{Sfn|Kane|1971|pp=30–39}}


The other ancient text, ''Naradiyasiksa'' dated to be from the 1st century BC, discusses secular and religious music, compares the respective musical notes.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}} This is earliest known text that reverentially names each musical note to be a deity, describing it in terms of ''varna'' (colors) and other motifs such as parts of fingers, an approach that is conceptually similar to the 12th century [[Guidonian hand]] in European music.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}} The study that mathematically arranges rhythms and modes (''rāga'') has been called ''prastāra'' (matrix).{{harv|Khan|1996|p=89, Quote: "(…) the Sanskrit word ''prastāra'', … means mathematical arrangement of rhythms and modes. In the Indian system of music there are about the 500 modes and 300 different rhythms which are used in everyday music. The modes are called Ragas."}}<ref>{{cite book|author1=Soubhik Chakraborty|author2=Guerino Mazzola|author3=Swarima Tewari|display-authors=etal|title=Computational Musicology in Hindustani Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0o2eBQAAQBAJ |year=2014|publisher=Springer|isbn=978-3-319-11472-9|pages=v–vi}};<br>{{cite book|author=Amiya Nath Sanyal|title=Ragas and Raginis| url=https://books.google.com/books?id=U_qVuQAACAAJ| year=1959| publisher=Orient Longmans|pages=18–20}}</ref>
The other ancient text, ''Naradiyasiksa'' dated to be from the 1st century BCE, discusses secular and religious music, compares the respective musical notes.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}} This is earliest known text that reverentially names each musical note to be a deity, describing it in terms of ''varna'' (colors) and other motifs such as parts of fingers, an approach that is conceptually similar to the 12th century [[Guidonian hand]] in European music.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}} The study that mathematically arranges rhythms and modes (''rāga'') has been called ''prastāra'' (matrix).{{harv|Khan|1996|p=89, Quote: "(…) the Sanskrit word ''prastāra'', … means mathematical arrangement of rhythms and modes. In the Indian system of music there are about the 500 modes and 300 different rhythms which are used in everyday music. The modes are called Ragas."}}<ref>{{cite book|author1=Soubhik Chakraborty|author2=Guerino Mazzola|author3=Swarima Tewari|display-authors=etal|title=Computational Musicology in Hindustani Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=0o2eBQAAQBAJ |year=2014|publisher=Springer|isbn=978-3-319-11472-9|pages=v–vi}};<br>{{cite book|author=Amiya Nath Sanyal|title=Ragas and Raginis| url=https://books.google.com/books?id=U_qVuQAACAAJ| year=1959| publisher=Orient Longmans|pages=18–20}}</ref>


In the ancient texts of Hinduism, the term for the technical mode part of ''rāga'' was ''Jati''. Later, ''Jati'' evolved to mean quantitative class of scales, while ''rāga'' evolved to become a more sophisticated concept that included the experience of the audience.{{Sfn|Caudhurī|2000|pp=48–50, 81}} A figurative sense of the word as 'passion, love, desire, delight' is also found in the ''[[Mahabharata]]''. The specialized sense of 'loveliness, beauty,' especially of voice or song, emerges in [[classical Sanskrit]], used by [[Kalidasa]] and in the ''[[Panchatantra]]''.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899}}
In the ancient texts of Hinduism, the term for the technical mode part of ''rāga'' was ''Jati''. Later, ''Jati'' evolved to mean quantitative class of scales, while ''rāga'' evolved to become a more sophisticated concept that included the experience of the audience.{{Sfn|Caudhurī|2000|pp=48–50, 81}} A figurative sense of the word as 'passion, love, desire, delight' is also found in the ''[[Mahabharata]]''. The specialized sense of 'loveliness, beauty,' especially of voice or song, emerges in [[classical Sanskrit]], used by [[Kalidasa]] and in the ''[[Panchatantra]]''.{{Sfn|Monier-Williams|1899}}


==History and significance==
==History and significance==
Classical music has ancient roots, and it primarily developed due to the reverence for arts, for both spiritual (''moksha'') and entertainment (''kama'') purposes in [[Hinduism]]. The [[Buddha]] discouraged music aimed at entertainment, but encouraged chanting of sacred hymns.<ref name="Tokita2008p38">{{cite book|author1=Alison Tokita|author2=Dr. David W. Hughes |title=The Ashgate Research Companion to Japanese Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=W2JTgQGc99EC&pg=PA38|year=2008|publisher=Ashgate Publishing|isbn=978-0-7546-5699-9|pages=38–39}}</ref> The various canonical ''[[Tripitaka]] '' texts of Buddhism, for example, state ''Dasha-shila'' or ten precepts for those following the Buddhist spiritual path. Among these is the precept recommending "abstain from dancing, singing, music and worldly spectacles".<ref>{{cite book|author=W. Y. Evans-Wentz|title=The Tibetan Book of the Great Liberation: Or the Method of Realizing Nirvana through Knowing the Mind |url=https://archive.org/details/tibetanbookofgre00carl |url-access=registration|year=2000|publisher=Oxford University Press|isbn=978-0-19-972723-0|pages=[https://archive.org/details/tibetanbookofgre00carl/page/111 111] with footnote 3}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author1=Frank Reynolds|author2=Jason A. Carbine|title=The Life of Buddhism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OnjDUqgFvToC&pg=PA184|year=2000|publisher=University of California Press|isbn=978-0-520-21105-6|page=184}}</ref> Buddhism does not forbid music or dance to a Buddhist layperson, but its emphasis has been on chants, not on musical ''rāga''.<ref name="Tokita2008p38"/>
Classical music has ancient roots, and it primarily developed due to the reverence for arts, for both spiritual (''moksha'') and entertainment (''kama'') purposes in [[Hinduism]].


''Rāga'', along with performance arts such as dance and music, has been historically integral to Hinduism, with some Hindus believing that music is itself a spiritual pursuit and a means to [[moksha]] (liberation).<ref name= Thompson1694>{{cite book|author=William Forde Thompson|title =Music in the Social and Behavioral Sciences: An Encyclopedia|url =https://books.google.com/books?id=kpmlBQAAQBAJ&pg=PT1694| year=2014 |publisher=SAGE Publications|isbn=978-1-4833-6558-9|pages=1693–1694}}; Quote: "Some Hindus believe that music is one path to achieving moksha, or liberation from the cycle of rebirth", (...) "The principles underlying this music are found in the Samaveda, (...)".</ref><ref name=mog17>{{cite web|title=The Mirror of Gesture|author=Coormaraswamy and Duggirala|publisher=Harvard University Press|year=1917| page=4| url= https://archive.org/stream/cu31924012568535#page/n5/mode/2up}}; Also see chapter 36</ref>{{Sfn|Beck|2012|pp=138–139.  Quote: "A summation of the signal importance of the Natyasastra for Hindu religion and culture has been provided by Susan {{harvtxt|Schwartz|2004|p=13}}, 'In short, the Natyasastra is an exhaustive encyclopedic dissertation of the arts, with an emphasis on performing arts as its central feature. It is also full of invocations to deities, acknowledging the divine origins of the arts and the central role of performance arts in achieving divine goals (...)'".}} ''Rāgas'', in the Hindu tradition, are believed to have a natural existence.{{Sfn|Dalal|2014|p=323}} Artists don't invent them, they only discover them. Music appeals to human beings, according to Hinduism, because they are hidden harmonies of the ultimate creation.{{Sfn|Dalal|2014|p=323}} Some of its ancient texts such as the ''[[Sama Veda]]'' (~1000 BC) are structured entirely to melodic themes,<ref name= Thompson1694/>{{Sfn|Beck|1993|pp=107–108}} it is sections of ''[[Rigveda]]'' set to music.{{Sfn|Staal|2009|pp=4–5}} The ''rāgas'' were envisioned by the Hindus as manifestation of the divine, a musical note treated as god or goddess with complex personality.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}}
''Rāga'', along with performance arts such as dance and music, has been historically integral to Hinduism, with some Hindus believing that music is itself a spiritual pursuit and a means to [[moksha]] (liberation).<ref name= Thompson1694>{{cite book|author=William Forde Thompson|title =Music in the Social and Behavioral Sciences: An Encyclopedia|url =https://books.google.com/books?id=kpmlBQAAQBAJ&pg=PT1694| year=2014 |publisher=SAGE Publications|isbn=978-1-4833-6558-9|pages=1693–1694}}; Quote: "Some Hindus believe that music is one path to achieving moksha, or liberation from the cycle of rebirth", (...) "The principles underlying this music are found in the Samaveda, (...)".</ref><ref name=mog17>{{cite web|title=The Mirror of Gesture|author=Coormaraswamy and Duggirala|publisher=Harvard University Press|year=1917| page=4| url= https://archive.org/stream/cu31924012568535#page/n5/mode/2up}}; Also see chapter 36</ref>{{Sfn|Beck|2012|pp=138–139.  Quote: "A summation of the signal importance of the Natyasastra for Hindu religion and culture has been provided by Susan {{harvtxt|Schwartz|2004|p=13}}, 'In short, the Natyasastra is an exhaustive encyclopedic dissertation of the arts, with an emphasis on performing arts as its central feature. It is also full of invocations to deities, acknowledging the divine origins of the arts and the central role of performance arts in achieving divine goals (...)'".}} ''Rāgas'', in the Hindu tradition, are believed to have a natural existence.{{Sfn|Dalal|2014|p=323}} Artists don't invent them, they only discover them. Music appeals to human beings, according to Hinduism, because they are hidden harmonies of the ultimate creation.{{Sfn|Dalal|2014|p=323}} Some of its ancient texts such as the ''[[Sama Veda]]'' (~1000 BCE) are structured entirely to melodic themes,<ref name= Thompson1694/>{{Sfn|Beck|1993|pp=107–108}} it is sections of ''[[Rigveda]]'' set to music.{{Sfn|Staal|2009|pp=4–5}} The ''rāgas'' were envisioned by the Hindus as manifestation of the divine, a musical note treated as god or goddess with complex personality.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=2}}


<!--###############A Sikh kirtan in raga Audio Begins#################-->
<!--###############A Sikh kirtan in raga Audio Begins#################-->
Line 43: Line 42:
}}
}}
<!--###############A Sikh kirtan in raga Audio Ends###################-->
<!--###############A Sikh kirtan in raga Audio Ends###################-->
During the [[Bhakti movement]] of Hinduism, dated to about the middle of 1st millennium AD, ''rāga'' became an integral part of a musical pursuit of spirituality. [[Bhajan]] and [[Kirtan]] were composed and performed by the early South India pioneers. A ''Bhajan'' has a free form devotional composition based on melodic ''rāgas''.<ref name="CushRobinson2012p87">{{cite book|author1=Denise Cush|author2=Catherine Robinson|author3=Michael York|title=Encyclopedia of Hinduism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kzPgCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA87 |year=2012|publisher=Routledge|isbn=978-1-135-18979-2 |pages=87–88 }}</ref>{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=247–253}} A ''Kirtan'' is a more structured team performance, typically with a [[Call and response (music)|call and response]] musical structure, similar to an intimate conversation. It includes two or more musical instruments,{{Sfn|Lavezzoli|2006|pp=371–72}}{{sfn|Brown|2014 |p=455, Quote:"Kirtan, (...), is the congregational singing of sacred chants and mantras in call-and-response format."; Also see, pp. 457, 474–475}} and incorporates various ''rāgas'' such as those associated with Hindu gods [[Shiva]] (''Bhairava'') or [[Krishna]] (''Hindola'').<ref>{{cite book|author1=Gregory D. Booth|author2=Bradley Shope|title=More Than Bollywood: Studies in Indian Popular Music |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kFwWDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA295 |year=2014|publisher=Oxford University Press|isbn=978-0-19-992883-5|pages=65, 295–298}}</ref>
During the [[Bhakti movement]] of Hinduism, dated to about the middle of 1st millennium CE, ''rāga'' became an integral part of a musical pursuit of spirituality. [[Bhajan]] and [[Kirtan]] were composed and performed by the early South India pioneers. A ''Bhajan'' has a free form devotional composition based on melodic ''rāgas''.<ref name="CushRobinson2012p87">{{cite book|author1=Denise Cush|author2=Catherine Robinson|author3=Michael York|title=Encyclopedia of Hinduism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kzPgCgAAQBAJ&pg=PA87 |year=2012|publisher=Routledge|isbn=978-1-135-18979-2 |pages=87–88 }}</ref>{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=247–253}} A ''Kirtan'' is a more structured team performance, typically with a [[Call and response (music)|call and response]] musical structure, similar to an intimate conversation. It includes two or more musical instruments,{{Sfn|Lavezzoli|2006|pp=371–72}}{{sfn|Brown|2014 |p=455, Quote:"Kirtan, (...), is the congregational singing of sacred chants and mantras in call-and-response format."; Also see, pp. 457, 474–475}} and incorporates various ''rāgas'' such as those associated with Hindu gods [[Shiva]] (''[[Bhairav (raga)|Bhairav]]'') or [[Krishna]] (''Hindola'').<ref>{{cite book|author1=Gregory D. Booth|author2=Bradley Shope|title=More Than Bollywood: Studies in Indian Popular Music |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=kFwWDAAAQBAJ&pg=PA295 |year=2014|publisher=Oxford University Press|isbn=978-0-19-992883-5|pages=65, 295–298}}</ref>


The early 13th century Sanskrit text ''[[Sangita Ratnakara|Sangitaratnakara]]'', by [[Sarngadeva]] patronized by King Sighana of the Yadava dynasty in [[Maharashtra]], mentions and discusses 253 ''rāgas''. This is one of the most complete historic treatises on the structure, technique and reasoning behind ''rāgas'' that has survived.{{Sfn|Rowell|2015|pp=12–13}}{{Sfn|Sastri|1943|pp=v–vi, ix–x (English), for ''raga'' discussion see pp. 169–274 (Sanskrit)}}{{Sfn | Powers| 1984| pp=352–353}}
The early 13th century Sanskrit text ''[[Sangita Ratnakara|Sangitaratnakara]]'', by [[Sarngadeva]] patronized by King Sighana of the Yadava dynasty in the [[Deccan Plateau|North-Central Deccan]] region (today a part of [[Maharashtra]]), mentions and discusses 253 ''rāgas''. This is one of the most complete historic treatises on the structure, technique and reasoning behind ''rāgas'' that has survived.{{Sfn|Rowell|2015|pp=12–13}}{{Sfn|Sastri|1943|pp=v–vi, ix–x (English), for ''raga'' discussion see pp. 169–274 (Sanskrit)}}{{Sfn | Powers| 1984| pp=352–353}}


The tradition of incorporating ''rāga'' into spiritual music is also found in [[Jainism]],{{Sfn|Kelting|2001|pp=28–29, 84}} and in [[Sikhism]], an Indian religion founded by [[Guru Nanak]] in the northwest of the Indian subcontinent.<ref>{{cite book|author1=Kristen Haar|author2=Sewa Singh Kalsi|title=Sikhism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=YOI1nB_zTyAC |year=2009|publisher=Infobase |isbn=978-1-4381-0647-2 |pages=60–61}}</ref> In the Sikh scripture, the texts are attached to a ''rāga'' and are sung according to the rules of that ''rāga''.<ref>{{cite book|author=Stephen Breck Reid|title=Psalms and Practice: Worship, Virtue, and Authority|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OyGqWnBY4KIC&pg=PA13|year=2001|publisher=Liturgical Press|isbn=978-0-8146-5080-6|pages=13–14}}</ref><ref name="Beck2006p156">{{cite book|author=Pashaura Singh|editor=Guy L. Beck|title=Sacred Sound: Experiencing Music in World Religions|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=t-IeHbqAfSsC&pg=PA156|year=2006|publisher=Wilfrid Laurier University Press|isbn=978-0-88920-421-8|pages=156–60}}</ref> According to Pashaura Singh – a professor of Sikh and Punjabi studies, the ''rāga'' and ''[[Tala (music)|tala]]'' of ancient Indian traditions were carefully selected and integrated by the Sikh Gurus into their hymns. They also picked from the "standard instruments used in Hindu musical traditions" for singing ''kirtans'' in Sikhism.<ref name="Beck2006p156"/>
The tradition of incorporating ''rāga'' into spiritual music is also found in [[Jainism]],{{Sfn|Kelting|2001|pp=28–29, 84}} and in [[Sikhism]], an Indian religion founded by [[Guru Nanak]] in the northwest of the Indian subcontinent.<ref>{{cite book|author1=Kristen Haar|author2=Sewa Singh Kalsi|title=Sikhism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=YOI1nB_zTyAC |year=2009|publisher=Infobase |isbn=978-1-4381-0647-2 |pages=60–61}}</ref> In the Sikh scripture, the texts are attached to a ''rāga'' and are sung according to the rules of that ''rāga''.<ref>{{cite book|author=Stephen Breck Reid|title=Psalms and Practice: Worship, Virtue, and Authority|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OyGqWnBY4KIC&pg=PA13|year=2001|publisher=Liturgical Press|isbn=978-0-8146-5080-6|pages=13–14}}</ref><ref name="Beck2006p156">{{cite book|author=Pashaura Singh|editor=Guy L. Beck|title=Sacred Sound: Experiencing Music in World Religions|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=t-IeHbqAfSsC&pg=PA156|year=2006|publisher=Wilfrid Laurier University Press|isbn=978-0-88920-421-8|pages=156–60}}</ref> According to Pashaura Singh – a professor of Sikh and Punjabi studies, the ''rāga'' and ''[[Tala (music)|tala]]'' of ancient Indian traditions were carefully selected and integrated by the Sikh Gurus into their hymns. They also picked from the "standard instruments used in Hindu musical traditions" for singing ''kirtans'' in Sikhism.<ref name="Beck2006p156"/>


During the Islamic rule period of the Indian subcontinent, particularly in and after the 15th century, the mystical Islamic tradition of [[Sufism]] developed devotional songs and music called ''[[qawwali]]''. It incorporated elements of ''rāga'' and ''tāla''.<ref>{{cite book|author=Paul Vernon|title=Ethnic and Vernacular Music, 1898–1960: A Resource and Guide to Recordings|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=gw--_c_LZMIC&pg=PA256 |year=1995|publisher=Greenwood Publishing|isbn=978-0-313-29553-9|page=256}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Regula Qureshi|title=Sufi Music of India and Pakistan: Sound, Context and Meaning in Qawwali|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=c3o9AAAAIAAJ|year=1986|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=978-0-521-26767-0|pages=xiii, 22–24, 32, 47–53, 79–85}}</ref>
During the Islamic rule period of the Indian subcontinent, particularly in and after the 15th century, the mystical Islamic tradition of [[Sufism]] developed devotional songs and music called ''[[qawwali]]''. It incorporated elements of ''rāga'' and ''tāla''.<ref>{{cite book|author=Paul Vernon|title=Ethnic and Vernacular Music, 1898–1960: A Resource and Guide to Recordings|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=gw--_c_LZMIC&pg=PA256 |year=1995|publisher=Greenwood Publishing|isbn=978-0-313-29553-9|page=256}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Regula Qureshi|title=Sufi Music of India and Pakistan: Sound, Context and Meaning in Qawwali|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=c3o9AAAAIAAJ|year=1986|publisher=Cambridge University Press|isbn=978-0-521-26767-0|pages=xiii, 22–24, 32, 47–53, 79–85}}</ref>
The [[Buddha]] discouraged music aimed at entertainment, but encouraged chanting of sacred hymns.<ref name="Tokita2008p38">{{cite book|author1=Alison Tokita|author2=Dr. David W. Hughes |title=The Ashgate Research Companion to Japanese Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=W2JTgQGc99EC&pg=PA38|year=2008|publisher=Ashgate Publishing|isbn=978-0-7546-5699-9|pages=38–39}}</ref> The various canonical ''[[Tripitaka]] '' texts of Buddhism, for example, state ''Dasha-shila'' or ten precepts for those following the Buddhist spiritual path. Among these is the precept recommending "abstain from dancing, singing, music and worldly spectacles".<ref>{{cite book|author=W. Y. Evans-Wentz|title=The Tibetan Book of the Great Liberation: Or the Method of Realizing Nirvana through Knowing the Mind |url=https://archive.org/details/tibetanbookofgre00carl |url-access=registration|year=2000|publisher=Oxford University Press|isbn=978-0-19-972723-0|pages=[https://archive.org/details/tibetanbookofgre00carl/page/111 111] with footnote 3}}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author1=Frank Reynolds|author2=Jason A. Carbine|title=The Life of Buddhism|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OnjDUqgFvToC&pg=PA184|year=2000|publisher=University of California Press|isbn=978-0-520-21105-6|page=184}}</ref> Buddhism does not forbid music or dance to a Buddhist layperson, but its emphasis has been on chants, not on musical ''rāga''.<ref name="Tokita2008p38"/>


==Description==
==Description==
A ''rāga'' is sometimes explained as a melodic rule set that a musician works with, but according to Dorottya Fabian and others, this is now generally accepted among music scholars to be an explanation that is too simplistic. According to them, a ''rāga'' of the ancient Indian tradition can be compared to the concept of non-constructible set in language for human communication, in a manner described by [[Frederik Kortlandt]] and [[George van Driem]].;{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–74}} audiences familiar with raga recognize and evaluate performances of them intuitively.
A ''rāga'' is sometimes explained as a melodic rule set that a musician works with, but according to Dorottya Fabian and others, this is now generally accepted among music scholars to be an explanation that is too simplistic. According to them, a ''rāga'' of the ancient Indian tradition can be compared to the concept of non-constructible set in language for human communication, in a manner described by [[Frederik Kortlandt]] and [[George van Driem]];{{Sfn|Fabian| Renee Timmers| Emery Schubert|2014|pp=173–74}} audiences familiar with raga recognize and evaluate performances of them intuitively.


[[File:Sitar Sarod Jugalbandi - lakshay & Aayush Mohan Gupta.jpg|thumb|upright=0.75|Two Indian musicians performing a ''rāga'' duet called ''[[Jugalbandi]]''.]]
[[File:Sitar Sarod Jugalbandi - lakshay & Aayush Mohan Gupta.jpg|thumb|upright=0.75|Two Indian musicians performing a ''rāga'' duet called ''[[Jugalbandi]]''.]]
Line 61: Line 62:
A ''rāga'' has a given set of notes, on a scale, ordered in melodies with musical motifs.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} A musician playing a ''rāga'', states [[Bruno Nettl]], may traditionally use just these notes, but is free to emphasize or improvise certain degrees of the scale.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} The Indian tradition suggests a certain sequencing of how the musician moves from note to note for each ''rāga'', in order for the performance to create a ''rasa'' (mood, atmosphere, essence, inner feeling) that is unique to each ''rāga''. A ''rāga'' can be written on a scale. Theoretically, thousands of ''rāga'' are possible given 5 or more notes, but in practical use, the classical tradition has refined and typically relies on several hundred.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} For most artists, their basic perfected repertoire has some forty to fifty ''rāgas''.{{Sfn|van der Meer|2012|p=5}} ''Rāga'' in Indian classic music is intimately related to ''[[Tala (music)|tala]]'' or guidance about "division of time", with each unit called a ''matra'' (beat, and duration between beats).{{Sfn|van der Meer|2012|pp=6–8}}
A ''rāga'' has a given set of notes, on a scale, ordered in melodies with musical motifs.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} A musician playing a ''rāga'', states [[Bruno Nettl]], may traditionally use just these notes, but is free to emphasize or improvise certain degrees of the scale.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} The Indian tradition suggests a certain sequencing of how the musician moves from note to note for each ''rāga'', in order for the performance to create a ''rasa'' (mood, atmosphere, essence, inner feeling) that is unique to each ''rāga''. A ''rāga'' can be written on a scale. Theoretically, thousands of ''rāga'' are possible given 5 or more notes, but in practical use, the classical tradition has refined and typically relies on several hundred.{{Sfn|Nettl|2010}} For most artists, their basic perfected repertoire has some forty to fifty ''rāgas''.{{Sfn|van der Meer|2012|p=5}} ''Rāga'' in Indian classic music is intimately related to ''[[Tala (music)|tala]]'' or guidance about "division of time", with each unit called a ''matra'' (beat, and duration between beats).{{Sfn|van der Meer|2012|pp=6–8}}


A ''rāga'' is not a tune, because the same ''rāga'' can yield an infinite number of tunes.{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}} A ''rāga'' is not a scale, because many ''rāgas'' can be based on the same scale.{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}}{{Sfn|Martinez|2001|pp=95–96}} A ''rāga'', according to Bruno Nettl and other music scholars, is a concept similar to a mode, something between the domains of tune and scale, and it is best conceptualized as a "unique array of melodic features, mapped to and organized for a unique aesthetic sentiment in the listener".{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}} The goal of a ''rāga'' and its artist is to create ''[[Rasa (aesthetics)|rasa]]'' (essence, feeling, atmosphere) with music, as [[classical Indian dance]] does with performance arts. In the Indian tradition, classical dances are performed with music set to various ''rāgas''.{{Sfn|Mehta|1995|pp=xxix, 248}}
A ''rāga'' is not a tune, because the same ''rāga'' can yield an infinite number of tunes.{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}} A ''rāga'' is not a scale, because many ''rāgas'' can be based on the same scale.{{Sfn|Martinez|2001|pp=95–96}}{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}} A ''rāga'', according to Bruno Nettl and other music scholars, is a concept similar to a mode, something between the domains of tune and scale, and it is best conceptualized as a "unique array of melodic features, mapped to and organized for a unique aesthetic sentiment in the listener".{{sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|p=67}} The goal of a ''rāga'' and its artist is to create ''[[Rasa (aesthetics)|rasa]]'' (essence, feeling, atmosphere) with music, as [[classical Indian dance]] does with performance arts. In the Indian tradition, classical dances are performed with music set to various ''rāgas''.{{Sfn|Mehta|1995|pp=xxix, 248}}


Joep Bor of the Rotterdam Conservatory of Music defined ''rāga'' as a "tonal framework for composition and improvisation."<ref name=Bor>{{cite book |title=The Raga Guide |last1=Bor |first1=Joep |last2=Rao |first2=Suvarnalata |last3=Van der Meer |first3=Wim |last4=Harvey |first4=Jane |year=1999 |publisher=[[Nimbus Records]] |isbn=978-0-9543976-0-9 |page=181|title-link=The Raga Guide }}</ref> [[Nazir Jairazbhoy]], chairman of [[University of California, Los Angeles|UCLA]]'s department of [[ethnomusicology]], characterized rāgas as separated by scale, line of ascent and descent, [[wiktionary:en:transilience|transilience]], emphasized notes and register, and intonation and [[Ornament (music)|ornaments]].{{Sfn|Jairazbhoy|1995|p=45}}
Joep Bor of the Rotterdam Conservatory of Music defined ''rāga'' as a "tonal framework for composition and improvisation."<ref name=Bor>{{cite book |title=The Raga Guide |last1=Bor |first1=Joep |last2=Rao |first2=Suvarnalata |last3=Van der Meer |first3=Wim |last4=Harvey |first4=Jane |year=1999 |publisher=[[Nimbus Records]] |isbn=978-0-9543976-0-9 |page=181|title-link=The Raga Guide }}</ref> [[Nazir Jairazbhoy]], chairman of [[University of California, Los Angeles|UCLA]]'s department of [[ethnomusicology]], characterized rāgas as separated by scale, line of ascent and descent, [[wiktionary:en:transilience|transilience]], emphasized notes and register, and intonation and [[Ornament (music)|ornaments]].{{Sfn|Jairazbhoy|1995|p=45}}
Line 67: Line 68:
=== Rāga-Rāgini system ===
=== Rāga-Rāgini system ===
{{For|illustrations of ragas and raginis|Ragamala paintings}}
{{For|illustrations of ragas and raginis|Ragamala paintings}}
Q Vasanta raga-ragini (Krishna).}}
 
''Rāginī'' ([[Devanagari]]: रागिनी) is a term for the "feminine" counterpart of a "masculine" rāga.{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=191–97}} These are envisioned to parallel the god-goddess themes in Hinduism, and described variously by different medieval Indian music scholars. For example, the ''Sangita-darpana'' text of 15th-century Damodara Misra proposes six ''rāgas'' with thirty ''ragini'', creating a system of thirty six, a system that became popular in [[Rajasthan]].{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=168–69}} In the north Himalayan regions such as [[Himachal Pradesh]], the music scholars such as 16th century Mesakarna expanded this system to include eight descendants to each ''rāga'', thereby creating a system of eighty four. After the 16th-century, the system expanded still further.{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=168–69}}
''Rāginī'' ([[Devanagari]]: रागिनी) is a term for the "feminine" counterpart of a "masculine" rāga.{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=191–97}} These are envisioned to parallel the god-goddess themes in Hinduism, and described variously by different medieval Indian music scholars. For example, the ''Sangita-darpana'' text of 15th-century Damodara Misra proposes six ''rāgas'' with thirty ''ragini'', creating a system of thirty six, a system that became popular in [[Rajasthan]].{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=168–69}} In the north Himalayan regions such as [[Himachal Pradesh]], the music scholars such as 16th century Mesakarna expanded this system to include eight descendants to each ''rāga'', thereby creating a system of eighty four. After the 16th-century, the system expanded still further.{{Sfn|Dehejia|2013|pages=168–69}}


Line 104: Line 105:
   | width=60px style="background: #ffad66;" | [[Swara|Svara]]<br>(Long)
   | width=60px style="background: #ffad66;" | [[Swara|Svara]]<br>(Long)
   | width=80px | Sadja<br>(षड्ज)
   | width=80px | Sadja<br>(षड्ज)
   | width=80px | Rsabha<br>(ऋषभ)
   | width=80px | Rishabha<br>(ऋषभ)
   | width= 80px | Gandhara<br>(गान्धार)
   | width= 80px | Gandhara<br>(गान्धार)
   | width= 80px | Madhyama<br>(मध्यम)
   | width= 80px | Madhyama<br>(मध्यम)
   | width=80px | Pañcama<br>(पञ्चम)
   | width=80px | Pañcham<br>(पञ्चम)
   | width= 80px | Dhaivata<br>(धैवत)
   | width= 80px | Dhaivata<br>(धैवत)
   | width=80px | Nisada<br>(निषाद)
   | width=80px | Nishada<br>(निषाद)
|-style="text-align: center;"
|-style="text-align: center;"
   | Svara<br>(Short)
   | Svara<br>(Short)
Line 161: Line 162:
|}
|}


The music theory in the ''Natyashastra'', states Maurice Winternitz, centers around three themes – sound, rhythm and prosody applied to musical texts.{{Sfn|Winternitz|2008|p=654}} The text asserts that the octave has 22 ''srutis'' or microintervals of musical tones or 1200 cents.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=14}} Ancient Greek system is also very close to it, states Emmie te Nijenhuis, with the difference that each ''sruti'' computes to 54.5 cents, while the Greek enharmonic quartertone system computes to 55 cents.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=14}} The text discusses ''gramas'' ([[Scale (music)|scales]]) and ''murchanas'' ([[Mode (music)|modes]]), mentioning three scales of seven modes (21 total), some Greek modes are also like them .{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=32-34}} However, the Gandhara-grama is just mentioned in ''Natyashastra'', while its discussion largely focuses on two scales, fourteen modes and eight four ''tanas'' ([[Musical note|notes]]).{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|pp=14–25}}<ref>{{cite book|author1=Reginald Massey |author2=Jamila Massey |title=The Music of India |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=1FSBJWkZofsC |year=1996|publisher=Abhinav Publications |isbn=978-81-7017-332-8 |pages=22–25 }}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Richa Jain |title=Song of the Rainbow: A Work on Depiction of Music Through the Medium of Paintings in the Indian Tradition |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=p6OfAAAAMAAJ|year=2002|publisher=Kanishka |isbn=978-81-7391-496-6|pages=26, 39–44}}</ref> The text also discusses which scales are best for different forms of performance arts.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=32-34}}
The music theory in the ''Natyashastra'', states Maurice Winternitz, centers around three themes – sound, rhythm and prosody applied to musical texts.{{Sfn|Winternitz|2008|p=654}} The text asserts that the octave has 22 ''srutis'' or microintervals of musical tones or 1200 cents.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=14}} Ancient Greek system is also very close to it, states Emmie te Nijenhuis, with the difference that each ''sruti'' computes to 54.5 cents, while the Greek enharmonic quartertone system computes to 55 cents.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=14}} The text discusses ''gramas'' ([[Scale (music)|scales]]) and ''murchanas'' ([[Mode (music)|modes]]), mentioning three scales of seven modes (21 total), some Greek modes are also like them .{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=32-34}} However, the Gandhara-grama is just mentioned in ''Natyashastra'', while its discussion largely focuses on two scales, fourteen modes and eight four ''tanas'' ([[Musical note|notes]]).{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|pp=14–25}}<ref>{{cite book|author1=Reginald Massey |author2=Jamila Massey |author2-link=Jamila Massey |title=The Music of India |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=1FSBJWkZofsC |year=1996|publisher=Abhinav Publications |isbn=978-81-7017-332-8 |pages=22–25 }}</ref><ref>{{cite book|author=Richa Jain |title=Song of the Rainbow: A Work on Depiction of Music Through the Medium of Paintings in the Indian Tradition |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=p6OfAAAAMAAJ|year=2002|publisher=Kanishka |isbn=978-81-7391-496-6|pages=26, 39–44}}</ref> The text also discusses which scales are best for different forms of performance arts.{{Sfn|Te Nijenhuis|1974|p=32-34}}


These musical elements are organized into scales (''mela''), and the South Indian system of ''rāga'' works with 72 scales, as first discussed by ''Caturdandi prakashika''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=815}} They are divided into two groups, ''purvanga'' and ''uttaranga'', depending on the nature of the lower tetrachord. The ''anga'' itself has six cycles (''cakra''), where the ''purvanga'' or lower tetrachord is anchored, while there are six permutations of ''uttaranga'' suggested to the artist.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=815}} After this system was developed, the Indian classical music scholars have developed additional ''rāgas'' for all the scales. The North Indian style is closer to the Western diatonic modes, and built upon the foundation developed by [[Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande]] using ten ''Thaat'': ''kalyan, bilaval, khamaj, kafi, asavari, bhairavi, bhairav, purvi, marva and todi''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|pp=815–816}} Some ''rāgas'' are common to both systems and have same names, such as ''kalyan'' performed by either is recognizably the same.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=816}} Some ''rāgas'' are common to both systems but have different names, such as ''malkos'' of Hindustani system is recognizably the same as ''hindolam'' of Carnatic system. However, some ''rāgas'' are named the same in the two systems, but they are different, such as ''todi''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=816}}
These musical elements are organized into scales (''mela''), and the South Indian system of ''rāga'' works with 72 scales, as first discussed by ''Caturdandi prakashika''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=815}} They are divided into two groups, ''purvanga'' and ''uttaranga'', depending on the nature of the lower tetrachord. The ''anga'' itself has six cycles (''cakra''), where the ''purvanga'' or lower tetrachord is anchored, while there are six permutations of ''uttaranga'' suggested to the artist.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=815}} After this system was developed, the Indian classical music scholars have developed additional ''rāgas'' for all the scales. The North Indian style is closer to the Western diatonic modes, and built upon the foundation developed by [[Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande]] using ten ''Thaat'': ''kalyan, bilaval, khamaj, kafi, asavari, bhairavi, bhairav, purvi, marva and todi''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|pp=815–816}} Some ''rāgas'' are common to both systems and have same names, such as ''kalyan'' performed by either is recognizably the same.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=816}} Some ''rāgas'' are common to both systems but have different names, such as ''malkos'' of Hindustani system is recognizably the same as ''hindolam'' of Carnatic system. However, some ''rāgas'' are named the same in the two systems, but they are different, such as ''todi''.{{Sfn|Randel|2003|p=816}}
Line 177: Line 178:
Janaka rāgas are grouped together using a scheme called ''[[Katapayadi]] sutra'' and are organised as ''Melakarta'' rāgas. A Melakarta rāga is one which has all seven notes in both the ārōhanam (ascending scale) and avarōhanam (descending scale). Some ''[[Melakarta]]'' rāgas are ''[[Harikambhoji]]'', ''[[Kalyani (rāga)|Kalyani]]'', ''[[Kharaharapriya]]'', ''[[Mayamalavagowla]]'', ''[[Sankarabharanam (raga)|Sankarabharanam]]'' and ''[[Hanumatodi]]''.<ref name="raganidhi">''Raganidhi'' by P. Subba Rao, Pub. 1964, The Music Academy of Madras</ref><ref name="ragas">''Ragas in Carnatic music'' by Dr. S. Bhagyalekshmy, Pub. 1990, CBH Publications</ref> [[Janya]] rāgas are derived from the Janaka rāgas using a combination of the swarams (usually a subset of swarams) from the parent rāga. Some janya rāgas are ''[[Abheri]]'', ''[[Abhogi]]'', ''[[Bhairavi (Carnatic)|Bhairavi]]'', ''[[Hindolam]]'', ''[[Mohanam]]'' and ''[[Kambhoji]]''.<ref name="raganidhi" /><ref name="ragas" />
Janaka rāgas are grouped together using a scheme called ''[[Katapayadi]] sutra'' and are organised as ''Melakarta'' rāgas. A Melakarta rāga is one which has all seven notes in both the ārōhanam (ascending scale) and avarōhanam (descending scale). Some ''[[Melakarta]]'' rāgas are ''[[Harikambhoji]]'', ''[[Kalyani (rāga)|Kalyani]]'', ''[[Kharaharapriya]]'', ''[[Mayamalavagowla]]'', ''[[Sankarabharanam (raga)|Sankarabharanam]]'' and ''[[Hanumatodi]]''.<ref name="raganidhi">''Raganidhi'' by P. Subba Rao, Pub. 1964, The Music Academy of Madras</ref><ref name="ragas">''Ragas in Carnatic music'' by Dr. S. Bhagyalekshmy, Pub. 1990, CBH Publications</ref> [[Janya]] rāgas are derived from the Janaka rāgas using a combination of the swarams (usually a subset of swarams) from the parent rāga. Some janya rāgas are ''[[Abheri]]'', ''[[Abhogi]]'', ''[[Bhairavi (Carnatic)|Bhairavi]]'', ''[[Hindolam]]'', ''[[Mohanam]]'' and ''[[Kambhoji]]''.<ref name="raganidhi" /><ref name="ragas" />


In this 21st century few composers  have discovered new ragas. Dr. M. Balamuralikrishna who has created raga in three notes<ref>{{Cite news|last=Ramakrishnan|first=Deepa H.|date=2016-11-23|title=Balamurali, a legend, who created ragas with three swaras|language=en-IN|work=The Hindu|url=https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/Balamurali-a-legend-who-created-ragas-with-three-swaras/article16684399.ece|access-date=2021-08-11|issn=0971-751X}}</ref> Ragas such as Mahathi, Lavangi, Sidhdhi, Sumukham that he created have only four notes,<ref>{{Cite web|date=2016-11-22|title=Carnatic singer M Balamuralikrishna passes away in Chennai, Venkaiah Naidu offers condolences-Entertainment News , Firstpost|url=https://www.firstpost.com/entertainment/carnatic-singer-m-balamurali-krishna-passes-away-3119230.html|access-date=2021-08-11|website=Firstpost}}</ref> Film & classical composer Mahesh Mahadev created Mukthipradayini, Amritha Kalyani, Nada Kalyani Srirangapriya, Thyagaraja Mangalam, Bhimsen and other ragas.<ref>{{Cite web|date=2021-08-10|title=Bengaluru composer creating new ragas|url=https://www.deccanherald.com/metrolife/metrolife-your-bond-with-bengaluru/bengaluru-composer-creating-new-ragas-1018393.html|access-date=2021-08-11|website=Deccan Herald|language=en}}</ref><ref>{{Cite news|last=Mary|first=S. B. Vijaya|date=2021-08-05|title=Mahesh Mahadev’s experiments with ragas|language=en-IN|work=The Hindu|url=https://www.thehindu.com/entertainment/music/experimenting-with-ragas/article35742833.ece|access-date=2021-08-11|issn=0971-751X}}</ref><ref>{{Cite book|last=Bharatiya Samagana Sabha|url=http://archive.org/details/saamagana-indian-classical-music-magazine-july-2018|title=Saamagana Indian Classical Music Magazine July 2018 - India’s Monthly Classical Music Magazine|date=2018-07-09}}</ref>
In this 21st century few composers  have discovered new ragas. Dr. M. Balamuralikrishna who has created raga in three notes<ref>{{Cite news|last=Ramakrishnan|first=Deepa H.|date=2016-11-23|title=Balamurali, a legend, who created ragas with three swaras|language=en-IN|work=The Hindu|url=https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/tamil-nadu/Balamurali-a-legend-who-created-ragas-with-three-swaras/article16684399.ece|access-date=2021-08-11|issn=0971-751X}}</ref> Ragas such as Mahathi, Lavangi, Sidhdhi, Sumukham that he created have only four notes,<ref>{{Cite web|date=2016-11-22|title=Carnatic singer M Balamuralikrishna passes away in Chennai, Venkaiah Naidu offers condolences-Entertainment News , Firstpost|url=https://www.firstpost.com/entertainment/carnatic-singer-m-balamurali-krishna-passes-away-3119230.html|access-date=2021-08-11|website=Firstpost}}</ref>


List of Janaka Ragas are ''[[Kanakangi]]'', ''[[Ratnangi]]'', Ganamurthi, ''[[Vanaspathi]]'', ''[[Manavathi]]'', Thanarupi, Senavathi, ''[[Hanumatodi]]'', ''[[Dhenuka]]'',  ''[[Natakapriya]]'', ''[[Kokilapriya]]'', ''[[Rupavati]]'', ''[[Gayakapriya]]'', ''[[Vakulabharanam]]'', ''[[Mayamalavagowla]]'', ''[[Chakravakam (raga)|Chakravakam]]'', ''[[Suryakantam]]'', ''[[Hatakambari]]'', ''[[Jhankaradhvani]]'', ''[[Natabhairavi]]'', ''[[Keeravani]]'', ''[[Kharaharapriya]]'', ''[[Gourimanohari]]'', ''[[Varunapriya]]'', ''[[Mararanjani]]'', ''[[Charukesi]]'', ''[[Sarasangi]]'', ''[[Harikambhoji]]'', ''[[Sankarabharanam (raga)|Sankarabharanam]]'', ''[[Naganandini]]'', ''[[Yagapriya]]'', ''[[Ragavardhini]]'', ''[[Gangeyabhushani]]'', ''[[Vagadheeswari]]'', ''[[Shulini]]'', ''[[Chalanata]]'', ''[[Salagam]]'', ''[[Jalarnavam]]'', ''[[Jhalavarali]]'', [[Navaneetam]], ''[[Pavani (raga)|Pavani]]''.
A list of Janaka Ragas would include ''[[Kanakangi]]'', ''[[Ratnangi]]'', Ganamurthi, ''[[Vanaspathi]]'', ''[[Manavathi]]'', Thanarupi, Senavathi, ''[[Hanumatodi]]'', ''[[Dhenuka]]'',  ''[[Natakapriya]]'', ''[[Kokilapriya]]'', ''[[Rupavati]]'', ''[[Gayakapriya]]'', ''[[Vakulabharanam]]'', ''[[Mayamalavagowla]]'', ''[[Chakravakam (raga)|Chakravakam]]'', ''[[Suryakantam]]'', ''[[Hatakambari]]'', ''[[Jhankaradhvani]]'', ''[[Natabhairavi]]'', ''[[Keeravani]]'', ''[[Kharaharapriya]]'', ''[[Gourimanohari]]'', ''[[Varunapriya]]'', ''[[Mararanjani]]'', ''[[Charukesi]]'', ''[[Sarasangi]]'', ''[[Harikambhoji]]'', ''[[Sankarabharanam (raga)|Sankarabharanam]]'', ''[[Naganandini]]'', ''[[Yagapriya]]'', ''[[Ragavardhini]]'', ''[[Gangeyabhushani]]'', ''[[Vagadheeswari]]'', ''[[Shulini]]'', ''[[Chalanata]]'', ''[[Salagam]]'', ''[[Jalarnavam]]'', ''[[Jhalavarali]]'', [[Navaneetam]], ''[[Pavani (raga)|Pavani]]''.


==Training==
==Training==
Classical music has been transmitted through music schools or through [[Guru]]–Shishya ''parampara'' (teacher–student tradition) through an [[oral tradition]] and practice. Some are known as ''[[gharana]]'' (houses), and their performances are staged through ''sabhas'' (music organizations).{{Sfn|Tenzer|2006|pp=303–309}}<ref>Sanyukta Kashalkar-Karve (2013), "Comparative Study of Ancient Gurukul System and the New Trends of Guru-Shishya Parampara," American International Journal of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Volume 2, Number 1, pages 81–84</ref> Each ''gharana'' has freely improvised over time, and differences in the rendering of each ''rāga'' is discernible. In the Indian musical schooling tradition, the small group of students lived near or with the teacher, the teacher treated them as family members providing food and boarding, and a student learnt various aspects of music thereby continuing the musical knowledge of his [[guru]].{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=457–467}} The tradition survives in parts of India, and many musicians can trace their guru lineage.{{Sfn|Ries|1969|p=22}}
Classical music has been transmitted through music schools or through [[Guru]]–Shishya ''parampara'' (teacher–student tradition) through an [[oral tradition]] and practice. Some are known as ''[[gharana]]'' (houses), and their performances are staged through ''sabhas'' (music organizations).{{Sfn|Tenzer|2006|pp=303–309}}<ref>Sanyukta Kashalkar-Karve (2013), "Comparative Study of Ancient Gurukul System and the New Trends of Guru-Shishya Parampara," American International Journal of Research in Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences, Volume 2, Number 1, pages 81–84</ref> Each ''gharana'' has freely improvised over time, and differences in the rendering of each ''rāga'' is discernible. In the Indian musical schooling tradition, the small group of students lived near or with the teacher, the teacher treated them as family members providing food and boarding, and a student learnt various aspects of music thereby continuing the musical knowledge of their [[guru]].{{Sfn|Nettl et al.|1998|pp=457–467}} The tradition survives in parts of India, and many musicians can trace their guru lineage.{{Sfn|Ries|1969|p=22}}


==Persian ''rāk''==
==Persian ''rāk''==
Line 199: Line 200:
* [[Raga rock]]
* [[Raga rock]]
* [[Arabic maqam]]
* [[Arabic maqam]]
*[[Dastgah|Persian dastgah]]


== References ==
== References ==
Line 225: Line 227:
*{{cite book|first=Ananda|last=Lal |title=The Oxford Companion to Indian Theatre |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=DftkAAAAMAAJ| year=2004| publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0-19-564446-3}}
*{{cite book|first=Ananda|last=Lal |title=The Oxford Companion to Indian Theatre |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=DftkAAAAMAAJ| year=2004| publisher=Oxford University Press |isbn=978-0-19-564446-3}}
*{{cite book|first=Peter|last=Lavezzoli|title=The Dawn of Indian Music in the West|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OSZKCXtx-wEC |year=2006|location=New York|publisher=Continuum|isbn=978-0-8264-1815-9}}
*{{cite book|first=Peter|last=Lavezzoli|title=The Dawn of Indian Music in the West|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OSZKCXtx-wEC |year=2006|location=New York|publisher=Continuum|isbn=978-0-8264-1815-9}}
*{{cite document|first=Natalia|last=Lidova|publisher=Oxford University Press |year=2014 |doi=10.1093/obo/9780195399318-0071 |title= Natyashastra }}
*{{cite book|first=Natalia|last=Lidova|publisher=Oxford University Press |year=2014 |doi=10.1093/obo/9780195399318-0071 |title= Natyashastra }}
*{{cite book|first=James G.|last=Lochtefeld|title=The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Hinduism, 2 Volume Set|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=5kl0DYIjUPgC|year=2002|publisher=The Rosen Publishing Group|isbn=978-0823922871}}
*{{cite book|first=James G.|last=Lochtefeld|title=The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Hinduism, 2 Volume Set|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=5kl0DYIjUPgC|year=2002|publisher=The Rosen Publishing Group|isbn=978-0823922871}}
*{{cite book|first=José Luiz|last=Martinez|title=Semiosis in Hindustani Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OwJRnFIcM4cC |year=2001|publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |isbn=978-81-208-1801-9}}
*{{cite book|first=José Luiz|last=Martinez|title=Semiosis in Hindustani Music|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=OwJRnFIcM4cC |year=2001|publisher=Motilal Banarsidass |isbn=978-81-208-1801-9}}
Anonymous user