Vedanga Jyotisha - Revision history

->BD2412: clean up spacing around commas and other punctuation, replaced: ,P → , P

2021-11-09T01:55:16Z

clean up spacing around commas and other punctuation, replaced: ,P → , P

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:25, 9 November 2021
Line 13:		Line 13:
	Other authors propose a later composition. Santanu Chakraverti writes that it has been composed after 700 BCE,{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} while [[Michael Witzel]] dates it to the last centuries BCE, based on the style of composing.{{sfn\|Witzel\|2001}} According to Chakraverti, its description of the [[winter solstice]] is correct for ca. 1400 BCE, but not for the time of its composition after 700 BCE.{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} This may be due to the incorporation of late Harappan astronomical knowledge into the Vedic fold,{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} an idea which is also proposed by Subbarayappa.{{sfn\|Subbarayappa\|1989\|pp=47–48}} Michael Witzel notes:		Other authors propose a later composition. Santanu Chakraverti writes that it has been composed after 700 BCE,{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} while [[Michael Witzel]] dates it to the last centuries BCE, based on the style of composing.{{sfn\|Witzel\|2001}} According to Chakraverti, its description of the [[winter solstice]] is correct for ca. 1400 BCE, but not for the time of its composition after 700 BCE.{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} This may be due to the incorporation of late Harappan astronomical knowledge into the Vedic fold,{{sfn\|Chakraverti\|2007\|p=33}} an idea which is also proposed by Subbarayappa.{{sfn\|Subbarayappa\|1989\|pp=47–48}} Michael Witzel notes:
	{{quote\|[O]nly if one is convinced that Lagadha intended the solstice to be exactly at alpha Delphini of Dhanishta, one can date his observations back to the late second millennium. Since that cannot be shown beyond doubt, since the composition of the text is in Late Epic language, and since its contents have clear resemblances to Babylonian works, the text must belong to a late period, to the last centuries BCE.{{sfn\|Witzel\|2001}}}}		{{quote\|[O]nly if one is convinced that Lagadha intended the solstice to be exactly at alpha Delphini of Dhanishta, one can date his observations back to the late second millennium. Since that cannot be shown beyond doubt, since the composition of the text is in Late Epic language, and since its contents have clear resemblances to Babylonian works, the text must belong to a late period, to the last centuries BCE.{{sfn\|Witzel\|2001}}}}

	[[Subhash Kak]] disputes the late chronology for the text and argues that it belongs to the second millennium BCE, which is consistent with its internal date. He argues that astronomy in India goes back to an earlier time than is taken by the votaries of the later date<ref>{{cite journal \|first=S. \|last=Kak \|pages=709–715 \|title=Knowledge of Planets in the Third Millennium BC \|journal=Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society \|volume=37 \|year=1996 \|bibcode=1996QJRAS..37..709K}} [ [http://adsbit.harvard.edu//full/1996QJRAS..37..709K/0000714.000.html p. 714] ]</ref> and, therefore, the internal date should not be set aside.

	== Editions ==		== Editions ==
Line 20:		Line 18:
	* Yajus recension, non-Yajus verses of Rk recension, edited: G. Thibaut, "Contributions to the Explanation of the Jyotisha-Vedánga", ''Journal of the Asiatic Society'' Bengal Vol 46 (1877), p. 411-437		* Yajus recension, non-Yajus verses of Rk recension, edited: G. Thibaut, "Contributions to the Explanation of the Jyotisha-Vedánga", ''Journal of the Asiatic Society'' Bengal Vol 46 (1877), p. 411-437
	*Hindi translation: Girja Shankar Shashtri, Jyotisha Karmkanda and Adhyatma Shodh Sansthan, 455 Vasuki Khurd, Daraganj, Allahabad-6.		*Hindi translation: Girja Shankar Shashtri, Jyotisha Karmkanda and Adhyatma Shodh Sansthan, 455 Vasuki Khurd, Daraganj, Allahabad-6.
	*Sanskrit Commentary with Hindi Translation: Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā. On Vedic astrology and astronomy; critical edited text with Hindi and Sanskrit commentaries. With appendies including Vedic calendar as described by Lagadha for his time. By Lagadha, Ācārya-Śivarāja Kauṇḍinnyāyana,Pramodavardhana Kaundinnyayana, Sammodavardhana Kauṇḍinnyāyana, Somākara<ref>{{Cite web \| url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SDmSGwAACAAJ \|title = Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā Somākarabhāṣyeṇa Kauṇḍinnyāyanavyākhyānena ca sahitam : Saṅkṣiptahindībhūmikā-Hindyānuvādādiyutaṃ vividhapariśiṣṭavibhūṣitaṃ ca\|author1 = Lagadha\|year = 2005}}</ref>		*Sanskrit Commentary with Hindi Translation: Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā. On Vedic astrology and astronomy; critical edited text with Hindi and Sanskrit commentaries. With appendies including Vedic calendar as described by Lagadha for his time. By Lagadha, Ācārya-Śivarāja Kauṇḍinnyāyana, Pramodavardhana Kaundinnyayana, Sammodavardhana Kauṇḍinnyāyana, Somākara<ref>{{Cite web \| url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SDmSGwAACAAJ \|title = Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā Somākarabhāṣyeṇa Kauṇḍinnyāyanavyākhyānena ca sahitam : Saṅkṣiptahindībhūmikā-Hindyānuvādādiyutaṃ vividhapariśiṣṭavibhūṣitaṃ ca\|author1 = Lagadha\|year = 2005}}</ref>

	== References ==		== References ==
Line 37:		Line 35:

	{{Portal bar\|India\|History\|Astronomy\|Stars\|Outer space\|Solar System\|Science}}		{{Portal bar\|India\|History\|Astronomy\|Stars\|Outer space\|Solar System\|Science}}

	[[Category:Hindu astrological texts]]		[[Category:Hindu astrological texts]]
	[[Category:Astronomy books]]		[[Category:Astronomy books]]
	[[Category:Vedangas]]		[[Category:Vedangas]]
	[[Category:Indian astronomy texts]]		[[Category:Indian astronomy texts]]
			[[Category:Ancient Indian astronomical works]]

	[[hi:लगध]]		[[hi:लगध]]
	[[sa:लगध]]		[[sa:लगध]]

imported>Whiteguru: + short desc + cat (this is a Hindu text)

2021-08-24T02:07:45Z

+ short desc + cat (this is a Hindu text)

New page

{{Short description|Hindu text on astrology}}
{{italic title}}
{{Use dmy dates|date=November 2014}}
{{Use Indian English|date=November 2014}}
{{Hinduism}}
'''Vedanga Jyotisha''' ({{IAST3|Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa}}), or '''Jyotishavedanga''' ({{IAST|Jyotiṣavedāṅga}}), is one of earliest known Indian texts on [[astrology]] (''[[Jyotisha]]'').<ref>{{cite book |title=Kalaprakasika |author=N. P. Subramania Iyer |date=1991 |publisher=[[Asian Educational Services]] |page=3}}</ref> The extant text is dated to the final centuries BCE,{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} but it may be based on a tradition reaching back to about 700-600 BCE.{{sfn|Subbarayappa|1989|pp=25–40}}

The text is foundational to Jyotisha, one of the six [[Vedanga]] disciplines.<ref>{{cite book |author=Hart Defouw |year=1996 |title=Light on Life: An Introduction to the Astrology of India |publisher=Penguin |url=https://archive.org/details/lightonlifeintro00defo |url-access=registration |page=[https://archive.org/details/lightonlifeintro00defo/page/3 3] |isbn=978-0-14-019507-1}}</ref> Its author is traditionally named as Lagadha.<ref>[[Debiprasad Chattopadhyaya]], ''History of Science and Technology in Ancient India'', Firma K.L Mukhopadhyaya (1986), pp. 486–494</ref><ref>[[Helaine Selin]], ''[[Encyclopaedia of the History of Science, Technology, and Medicine in Non-Western Cultures]]'', [[Kluwer Academic Publishers]] (1997), p. 977</ref>{{sfn|Chakraverti|2007|p=33}}

== Textual history ==
The dating of the ''Vedanga Jyotisha'' is relevant for the dating of the Vedic texts.{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} The ''Vedanga Jyotisha'' describes the winter solstice for the period of ca. 1400 BCE. This description has been used to date the ''Vedanga Jyotisha''.{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} According to Michael Witzel, the question is "whether the description as given in the Jyotisha is also the date of the text in which it is transmitted. It is written in two recensions – Rigveda recensions and Yajurveda recensions. Rigveda recensions and Yajurveda recensions have same verses except for eight additional verses in the Yajurveda's one".{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} T. K. S. Sastry and R. Kochhar suppose that the ''Vedanga Jyotisha'' was written in the period that it describes, and therefore propose an early date, between 1370 and 1150 BCE.{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} [[David Pingree]] dates the described solstice as about 1180 BCE, but notes that the relevance of this computation to the date of the ''Vedanga Jyotisha'' is not evident.<ref>{{Citation | last = Pingree | first = David | author-link = David Pingree | date = 1973 | title = The Mesopotamian Origin of Early Indian Mathematical Astronomy | journal = Journal for the History of Astronomy | volume = 4 | pages = 1–12 | bibcode = 1973JHA.....4....1P | doi = 10.1177/002182867300400102 | s2cid = 125228353 }}</ref> The estimation of 1400-1200 BCE has been followed by others,{{sfn|Klostermaier|2010|p=977}}{{sfn|Subbarayappa|1989|p=29}} with Subbarayappa adding that the extant form can possibly be from 700-600 BCE.{{sfn|Subbarayappa|1989|p=29}}

Other authors propose a later composition. Santanu Chakraverti writes that it has been composed after 700 BCE,{{sfn|Chakraverti|2007|p=33}} while [[Michael Witzel]] dates it to the last centuries BCE, based on the style of composing.{{sfn|Witzel|2001}} According to Chakraverti, its description of the [[winter solstice]] is correct for ca. 1400 BCE, but not for the time of its composition after 700 BCE.{{sfn|Chakraverti|2007|p=33}} This may be due to the incorporation of late Harappan astronomical knowledge into the Vedic fold,{{sfn|Chakraverti|2007|p=33}} an idea which is also proposed by Subbarayappa.{{sfn|Subbarayappa|1989|pp=47–48}} Michael Witzel notes:
{{quote|[O]nly if one is convinced that Lagadha intended the solstice to be exactly at alpha Delphini of Dhanishta, one can date his observations back to the late second millennium. Since that cannot be shown beyond doubt, since the composition of the text is in Late Epic language, and since its contents have clear resemblances to Babylonian works, the text must belong to a late period, to the last centuries BCE.{{sfn|Witzel|2001}}}}

[[Subhash Kak]] disputes the late chronology for the text and argues that it belongs to the second millennium BCE, which is consistent with its internal date. He argues that astronomy in India goes back to an earlier time than is taken by the votaries of the later date<ref>{{cite journal |first=S. |last=Kak |pages=709–715 |title=Knowledge of Planets in the Third Millennium BC |journal=Quarterly Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society |volume=37 |year=1996 |bibcode=1996QJRAS..37..709K}} [ [http://adsbit.harvard.edu//full/1996QJRAS..37..709K/0000714.000.html p. 714] ]</ref> and, therefore, the internal date should not be set aside.

== Editions ==
* Yajus recension, Rk variants and commentary of Somākara Śeṣanāga, edited: Albrecht Weber, ''[https://books.google.com/books?id=YxYpAAAAYAAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false Über den Vedakalender Namens Jyotisham]'', Berlin 1862
* Yajus recension, non-Yajus verses of Rk recension, edited: G. Thibaut, "Contributions to the Explanation of the Jyotisha-Vedánga", ''Journal of the Asiatic Society'' Bengal Vol 46 (1877), p. 411-437
*Hindi translation: Girja Shankar Shashtri, Jyotisha Karmkanda and Adhyatma Shodh Sansthan, 455 Vasuki Khurd, Daraganj, Allahabad-6.
*Sanskrit Commentary with Hindi Translation: Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā. On Vedic astrology and astronomy; critical edited text with Hindi and Sanskrit commentaries. With appendies including Vedic calendar as described by Lagadha for his time. By Lagadha, Ācārya-Śivarāja Kauṇḍinnyāyana,Pramodavardhana Kaundinnyayana, Sammodavardhana Kauṇḍinnyāyana, Somākara<ref>{{Cite web | url=https://books.google.com/books?id=SDmSGwAACAAJ |title = Vedā̄ṅgajyotiṣam: Yajurvedināṃ paramparayā''gatam vistr̥tasaṃskr̥tabhūmikayā Somākarabhāṣyeṇa Kauṇḍinnyāyanavyākhyānena ca sahitam : Saṅkṣiptahindībhūmikā-Hindyānuvādādiyutaṃ vividhapariśiṣṭavibhūṣitaṃ ca|author1 = Lagadha|year = 2005}}</ref>

== References ==
{{Reflist|2}}

== Sources ==
{{refbegin}}
* {{Citation | last =Chakraverti | first =Santanu | date =2007 | title =Science in History. In: Jyoti Bhusan Das Gupta (ed.), "Science, Technology, Imperialism, and War" | publisher =Pearson Education India}}
* {{Citation | last =Klostermaier | first =Klaus | date =2010 | title =A Survey of Hinduism | edition =Third | publisher =SUNY| url =https://books.google.com/books?id=8CVviRghVtIC&pg=PA469| isbn =978-0-7914-8011-3 }}
* {{cite book | last =Subbarayappa | first =B.V. | year =1989 | chapter =Indian astronomy: a historical perspective |editor-last1=Biswas |editor-first1=S. K. |editor-last2=Mallik |editor-first2=D. C. V. |editor-last3=Vishveshwara |editor-first3=C. V. |editor-link3=C. V. Vishveshwara |title=Cosmic Perspectives |publisher=Cambridge University Press |chapter-url=https://books.google.com/books?id=PFTGKi8fjvoC&pg=FA25 |isbn=978-0-521-34354-1}}
* {{cite journal |last =Witzel |first =Michael |title =Autochthonous Aryans? The Evidence from Old Indian and Iranian Texts |journal =Electronic Journal of Vedic Studies |date=25 May 2001 |issue=3 |volume=7 |url=http://www.people.fas.harvard.edu/~witzel/EJVS-7-3.htm}}
{{refend}}

== External links ==
* [https://web.archive.org/web/20110501084408/http://www.new.dli.ernet.in/rawdataupload/upload/insa/INSA_1/20005abd_s1.pdf TSK Sastry translation, edited by KV Sarma]

{{Portal bar|India|History|Astronomy|Stars|Outer space|Solar System|Science}}
[[Category:Hindu astrological texts]]
[[Category:Astronomy books]]
[[Category:Vedangas]]
[[Category:Indian astronomy texts]]

[[hi:लगध]]
[[sa:लगध]]