>Lembit Staan: /* Kerala */ an example how to carry out editing disputes without revert war; see the talk page now

2021-06-20T17:54:59Z

Kerala: an example how to carry out editing disputes without revert war; see the talk page now

New page

{{Short description|Overview of the prevalence and impact of the caste system among South Asian Christian communities}}
The '''caste system among South Asian Christians''' often reflects stratification by sect, location, and the [[Indian caste system]] of their predecessors.<ref name="britannica">[http://concise.britannica.com/ebc/article-9360711/Christian-caste Christian Castes] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20061129202451/http://concise.britannica.com/ebc/article-9360711/Christian-caste# |date=2006-11-29 }} Encyclopædia Britannica</ref> There exists evidence to show that Christian individuals have mobility within their respective castes.<ref name="fuller">{{cite journal |title=Kerala Christians and the Caste System |first=C. J. |last=Fuller |journal=Man |series=New series |volume=11 |issue=1 |date=March 1976 |pages=53–70 |doi=10.2307/2800388 |jstor=2800388 }}</ref> But, in some cases, social inertia caused from their old traditions and biases against other castes to remain, causing caste system to persist among South Asian Christians to some extent.<ref name="AqeelFaruqi2018">{{cite web |last1=Aqeel |first1=Asif |last2=Faruqi |first2=Sama |title=Caste away: The ongoing struggle of Punjabi Christians |url=https://herald.dawn.com/news/1153539 |publisher=[[Herald (Pakistan)|Herald Magazine]] |access-date=25 May 2021 |language=English |date=26 February 2018}}</ref><ref name="Khadka2016"/><ref name="britannica2">{{cite encyclopedia|url=http://www.britannica.com/eb/article-9082413/Christian-caste|title=Christian caste|encyclopedia=Encyclopædia Britannica|accessdate=14 June 2015}}</ref><ref>[https://books.google.com/books?id=kBTkAAAAMAAJ Struggle for justice to Untouchable Christians] Brojendra Nath Banerjee, Uiliyāma Kerī Sṭāḍi eyāṇḍ Risārca Seṇṭāra. Page 42: "At stake is the fate of 16 million Christians of SC origin, who form 70–80 percent of the Christians in the country"</ref><ref>Carol Henderson Garcia, Carol E. Henderson 2002:40 "Today about 70 percent of Christians are Dalits"</ref><ref>Radhakrishnan 2005:23</ref><ref>Azariah 1985:5</ref> Christian priests, nuns, Dalits and similar groups are found in [[India]], [[Pakistan]], [[Bangladesh]], and [[Nepal]].<ref>{{cite book|title = Ethnographic discourse of the other: conceptual and methodological issues|pages = 39–116|author1=Panchanan Mohanty |author2=Ramesh C. Malik |author3=Eswarappa Kasi |publisher = Cambridge Scholars|year = 2009}}</ref>

==South Asia==
===Kerala===
[[Saint Thomas Christians|Nasrani]], [[Saint Thomas Christians|Syrian Christians]], [[Knanaya]], [[Anglo-Indian]] in Kerala belong to different denominations and have different types of heritages like [[Arabian]], [[Brahmin]], [[Nair]], [[Nambudiri]], [[English people|English]], [[Portuguese people|Portuguese]] and [[Jewish]] and intermarriage between different denominations is rare. [[Saint Thomas Christians|Saint Thomas Syrian Christians]] in Kerala consist of the members of ([[Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church]], [[Jacobite Syrian Christian Church|Malankara Jacobite Syrian Church]], [[Mar Thoma Syrian Church]], [[Malabar Independent Syrian Church|Thozhiyur Syrian Church]], [[Syro-Malabar Church|Syro Malabar Catholic Church]], [[Syro-Malankara Catholic Church|Syro Malankara Catholic Church]], [[Chaldean Syrian Church]], [[Knanaya|Knanaya Church]]) and form 70.73% of the christians in the state. Protestant churches in Kerala are Pentecostal communities mainly ([[India Pentecostal Church of God]], [[Assemblies of God in India]], [[Church of God (Full Gospel) in India]] and [[The Pentecostal Mission]]) form 9.77% of the christians. The Anglican CSI Church constitutes 4.5% of the christians .The [[Latin Church|Latin Catholics]] form 13.3% of the christians in Kerala. The [[Dalit Christian|Dalit and Nadar christians]] of the state combined form 2.6% of the Christian community.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.kcbcsite.com/kerala1.php|title=KCBC|website=www.kcbcsite.com}}</ref> In the colonial period, many lower castes were converted to Christians by the European Missionaries but the new converts were not allowed to join the [[Saint Thomas Christian|Saint Thomas Syrian Christian]] community and they continued to be considered as untouchables even by the Syrian Christians. The Saint Thomas Syrian Christians claim to derive status within the caste system from the tradition that they were descendants of Assyrians, Jews and that they were Upper castes,{{dubious|date=June 2021}} who were evangelized by [[Thomas the Apostle]].<ref name="Fuller1976p55">Fuller (1976), pp. 55-56.</ref><ref name="Fuller, C.J 1977 pp. 528-529">Fuller, C.J. "Indian Christians: Pollution and Origins." ''[[Man (journal)|Man]]''. New Series, Vol. 12, No. 3/4. (Dec. 1977), pp. 528–529.</ref><ref>Amaladass (1993), pp. 15-19.</ref> Anand Amaladass says that "The Syrian Christians had inserted themselves within the Indian caste society for centuries and were regarded by the Hindus as a caste occupying a high place within their caste hierarchy."<ref>Amaladass (1993), p. 18.</ref> Saint Thomas Syrian Christians followed the same rules of caste and pollution as that of Hindus and they were considered as pollution neutralizers.<ref name="Fuller1976p55" /><ref name="Benedict325">Vadakkekara, Benedict (2007). [https://books.google.com/books?id=pAncGlpGW8wC&pg=PA91 ''Origin of Christianity in India: a Historiographical Critique''], pp. 325–330. Media House Delhi.</ref> Rajendra Prasad, an Indian historian, said that the Syrian Christians took ritual baths after physical contact with lower castes .<ref>{{cite book |last=Prasad |first=Rajendra |title=A Historical Developmental Study of Classical Indian Philosophy of Morals |year=2009 |volume=12 |publisher=Concept Publishing |isbn=978-8-18069-595-7 |url=https://books.google.com/books?id=1gtxVmUr1ygC&pg=PA484}}</ref><ref>{{Cite web|title=Why Christo-Racist Nationalism and Anti-Muslim Rhetoric Are Gaining Ground in Kerala|url=https://thewire.in/religion/kerala-syrian-christians-caste-anti-muslim-rhetoric|access-date=2021-06-17|website=thewire.in|language=en}}</ref>

===Goa, [[Konkan]] and [[Canara]]===
In [[Portuguese Bombay and Bassein]], [[Portuguese Goa and Damaon]] and other [[Portuguese India]]n possessions, conversions of entire villages were carried out by Catholic missionaries from the 16th century onwards. The Hindu [[Konkani Brahmins]] and [[Kayastha]]s ([[Prabhu]]s) of the region became Catholic ''[[Roman Catholic Brahmin|Bamonns]]'', and the [[Kshatriya]] and [[Vaishya Vani]]s became ''[[Roman Catholic Kshatriya|Chardos]]''.<ref name="Spicer2016">{{cite book|author=Andrew Spicer|title=Parish Churches in the Early Modern World|date=2016|publisher=Taylor & Francis}}</ref> However, the Hindu converts were not allowed to practice their Hindu customs because of the [[Goa Inquisition]].<ref name="Mendonça">{{cite book
|title=Conversions and citizenry: Goa under Portugal, 1510–1610
|author=Délio de Mendonça
|date=1958
|publisher=Concept Publishing Company}}</ref> Intermarriage of the majority of the native converts and their offspring across castes and even with the [[Portuguese people|Portuguese]] also meant that their descendants could not claim caste purity.<ref>{{cite book
|first=Roger
|last=Crowley
|year=2015
|title=Conquerors: How Portugal Forged the First Global Empire
|publisher=Faber & Faber
|location=London}}</ref>

===Punjab and Uttar Pradesh===
In [[colonial India]], there were waves of [[conversion to Christianity|conversions to Christianity]] among the [[Chuhra]] and [[Chamar]] in the [[Punjab Province (British India)|Punjab Province]] and [[United Provinces of Agra and Oudh]]; they thus became known as [[Dalit Christians]].<ref>{{cite book |last1=Frykenberg |first1=Robert Eric |title=Christianity in India: From Beginnings to the Present |date=26 June 2008 |publisher=[[Oxford University Press]] |isbn=978-0-19-826377-7 |page=240 |language=English}}</ref><ref name="SinghaAriel2015">{{cite web |last1=Singha |first1=Sara |last2=Ariel |first2=Glucklich |title=Dalit Christians and Caste Consciousness in Pakistan |url=https://repository.library.georgetown.edu/handle/10822/761014 |accessdate=22 September 2020 |language=English |date=23 April 2015 |quote=This study explores caste discrimination in Pakistan against untouchable (Dalit) converts to Christianity. During the nineteenth century in India, many Dalits converted to Christianity to escape caste persecution. In the 1870s in Punjab, a mass movement to Protestant Christianity flourished among the Dalit Chuhra caste. The Chuhras were the largest menial caste in Punjab and engaged in degrading occupations including sweeping and sanitation work. By the 1930s, almost the entire Chuhra caste converted to Protestant Christianity.}}</ref> The Chuhra sub-castes found in Pakistan and India include the [[Sahotra]], [[Gill (name)|Gill]], [[Khokhar]], [[Mattoo]], [[Bhati|Bhatti]], among other sub-castes.<ref name="Singh1995">{{cite book |last1=Singh |first1=Kumar Suresh |title=The Scheduled Castes, Volume 10 |date=1995 |publisher=[[Oxford University Press]] |isbn=9780195637427 |page=108 |language=English |quote=Ibbetson (1916) records several Chuhra tribes (divisions), namely Sahotra, Gill, Bhatti, Khokhar, Mattu, Kharu, Kaliyana, Ladhar, Sindhu, Chhapriband, Untwal, Kandabari, Hansi, Khosar, Borat and Dharival.}}</ref>

===Sindh===
In the province of [[Sindh]], Christians of lower castes are often the victims of forced marriages.<ref name="Ebrahim2020">{{cite web |last1=Ebrahim |first1=Zofeen T. |title=Pakistan court orders arrests over Christian teen's forced marriage |url=https://www.reuters.com/article/us-pakistan-women-childmarriage-trfn/pakistan-court-orders-arrests-over-christian-teens-forced-marriage-idUSKBN27P28Y |publisher=[[Reuters]] |access-date=25 May 2021 |language=English |date=9 November 2020|quote=Campaigners say forced conversion and marriage of girls and women from minority religions, including Hindus and Christians, is a growing problem in Muslim-majority Pakistan, with those from poor families and low castes largely targeted.}}</ref>

===Tamil Nadu===
Majority of Christians in the state hail from the [[Paravar]], [[Mukkuvar]], [[Udayar (caste)]], [[Nadar (caste)|Nadar]], and [[Adi Dravida]]r. The mass conversion of [[Paravar]]s date back to the Portuguese era and the conflict over the [[Pearl Fishery Coast]] between the Paravars and arabs in the 15th century A.D.The Paravars converted 'en masse' to Christianity and became the subjects of the Portuguese king. The [[Nadar (caste)|Nadar]] conversion to Christianity dates back to the British Colonial Era in the 18th-century. The first to initiate the conversion was [[Mylaudy]] village by Sir Ringle Taube. Later in the 19th century, the [[Vellalar]]s, the Udaiyars and [[Schedule castes]] embraced Christianity. The cohesion of ''[[Jāti|jati]]s'' among caste Christians (e.g. Paravas) and the strength of caste leadership are noted by scholars to be much stronger than comparable predominantly Hindu castes in [[Tamil Nadu]].<ref name="kau">Kauffman, S. B. "A Christian Caste in Hindu Society: Religious Leadership and Social Conflict among the Paravas of Southern Tamilnadu." ''Modern Asian Studies''. 15, No. 2, (1981)</ref> The Christians of Tamil Nadu denote themselves as RC (Roman Catholic) [[Paravar]], CSI Nadar etc., i.e., they use a combination of the Church and their Hindu caste name. Robert L. Hardgrave, a Professor of Humanities, notes in his work ''The Nadars of TamilNad..'' that a Christian Nadar would enter into a marital alliance with a Hindu Nadar but never with a Christian of another caste and that they would dine with their Hindu brethren but never with a person of their own faith who was beneath them in the social scale. As per a native pastor, "Caste sticks to the people as closely as their skins. The blood of caste was thicker than the spirit of religion."<ref>{{cite book|url=https://archive.org/details/nadarsoftamilnad0000hard|url-access=registration|quote=tamil rc vellalar csi nadar.|title=The Nadars of Tamilnad|year=1969|author=Robert L. Hardgrave|publisher=University of California Press|page=[https://archive.org/details/nadarsoftamilnad0000hard/page/91 91]}}</ref>

===Nepal===
In [[Nepal]], Christians often enter into canonically [[interfaith marriage]]s with members of the same caste.<ref name="Khadka2016">{{cite web |last1=Khadka |first1=Prakash |title=Marriage: Making sense of Nepal's complex culture |url=https://www.ucanews.com/news/marriage-making-sense-of-nepals-complex-culture/76429 |publisher=[[UCA News]] |access-date=25 May 2021 |language=English |date=29 June 2016|quote=Even though the caste system is understood as a Hindu system, this practice is hidden and embedded within the Nepalese Christian community, especially when it comes to marriage. ... Therefore, inter-faith and inter-caste marriages are two different realities of the Nepalese Christian community. It is not possible for us to avoid mixed marriages in our small community. When young people look around for their life partner, they can't find someone suitable from their community and this leads them to search for someone outside of their community. Mixed marriages happen in the end.}}</ref>

==Under the law==
Indian law does not provide benefits for Scheduled Caste Christians, however Christians have been advocating for the same rights given to Hindu, [[Buddhist]], and [[Sikh]] [[Scheduled castes]].<ref>{{Cite web|url=https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2015/04/21/by-2050-india-to-have-worlds-largest-populations-of-hindus-and-muslims/|title=By 2050, India to have world's largest populations of Hindus and Muslims}}</ref> Despite the activists' point that Christians are a casteless society discrimination does not go away easily and Dalits seek equal rights irrespective of the religion they profess.<ref>{{cite news |url=http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/India/Do_Christians_also_practise_caste_system_asks_SC/articleshow/2218560.cms |title=Do Christians also practise caste system, asks SC |newspaper=Times of India |date=July 20, 2007}}</ref>

Some Christians also oppose the proposed labeling of "Christian [[Scheduled caste]]s" because they feel their identity may be assimilated. Pastor Salim Sharif of the [[Church of North India]] notes "We are becoming another class and caste."<ref>Sharif interview 17 November 1996</ref>

==Caste discrimination among Christians==

===Criticism===
Many Catholics have spoken out against discrimination against them by members of the Catholic Church. A Dalit activist with a ''nom-de-plume'' of Bama Faustina has written books that are critical of the discrimination by the nuns and priests in Churches in South India (CSI).<ref>[http://www.hinduonnet.com/2001/09/16/stories/1316017m.htm A palmyra leaf that sears us] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20071013195127/http://hinduonnet.com/2001/09/16/stories/1316017m.htm |date=2007-10-13 }} [[The Hindu]] – September 16, 2001</ref> During 2003 [[ad limina]] visits of the bishops of India, [[Pope John Paul II]] criticized the caste discrimination in the [[Catholic Church in India]] when addressing bishops of the ecclesiastical provinces of [[Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Madras and Mylapore|Madras-Mylapore]], [[Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Madurai|Madurai]] and [[Roman Catholic Archdiocese of Pondicherry and Cuddalore|Pondicherry-Cuddalore]], the three archbishops of Tamil Nadu. He went on to say: "It is the Church's obligation to work unceasingly to change hearts, helping all people to see every human being as a child of God, a brother or sister of Christ, and therefore a member of our own family".<ref>{{cite web|title=Address to the Bishops of India on their ad Limina visit|url=https://www.vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/speeches/2003/november/documents/hf_jp-ii_spe_20031117_ad-limina-india_en.html|accessdate=17 November 2003}}</ref><ref>[http://www.zenit.org/article-8716?l=english Papal Address to Bishops of Madras-Mylapore, Madurai and Pondicherry-Cuddalore] {{Webarchive|url=https://web.archive.org/web/20080922115639/http://zenit.org/article-8716?l=english# |date=2008-09-22 }} ZENIT – November 17, 2003</ref><ref>[http://www.dalitchristians.com/Html/arulappa.htm Problems and Struggles] Dalitchristians.com</ref>

===Dalit Christians===
Mass conversions of lower caste Hindus to Christianity and Islam took place in order to escape the discrimination. The main Dalit groups that participated in these conversions were the Chuhras of Punjab, Chamars of North India (Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and Madhya Pradesh), Vankars of Gujarat and Pulayas of Kerala.<ref name="Dalit Christians In India">[http://www.dalitstudies.org.in/uploads/publication/1473146694.pdf Dalit Christians In India] Sobin George 2012</ref> They believed that “Christianity is a true religion; a desire for protection from oppressors and, if possible, material aid; the desire for education for their children; and the knowledge that those who have become Christians had improved”.<ref>South Indian Missionary Congress. 1908. ‘The Report of Conference Held at Madras’</ref> Christianity was thought to be egalitarian and could provide mobility away from the caste. Even after conversion, in some cases, Dalits were discriminated against due to the “residual leftover” practice of caste discrimination from their previous traditions.<ref>[‘Homo Hierarchicus: The Caste System and its Implications’, Complete Revised Edition, Chicago: Chicago University Press] Dumont, Louis. 1980.</ref> This is attributed to the predominant Hindu society they lived in. Sometimes the only change seen was their personal religious identity. In many cases they were still referred to by their Hindu caste names. Example Pulayans in Kerala, Pariah in Tamil Nadu and Madigas in Andra Pradesh by members of all religious backgrounds.<ref>[‘Caste-based Discrimination and Atrocities on Dalit Christians and the Need for Reservations’, Working Paper Series, II(04): New Delhi: Indian Institute of Dalit Studies.] Louis, Prakash. 2007.</ref>

The first people converted by [[Society of Jesus|Jesuits]] of the Madura Mission to Christianity were members of Nadars, Maravars and Pallar .<ref>[The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute Vol. 2, No. 3 (Sep., 1996)] David Mosse.</ref> Caste based occupations held by Dalits also show a clear segregation which perpetuated even after becoming Christian. Occupational patterns (including manual scavenging) are prevalent among Dalit Christians in north-west India are said to be quite similar to that of Dalit Hindus.<ref>[ ‘Rural Christian Community in North West India’, New Delhi] Dogar, Vidya Sagar. 2000.</ref> Occupational discrimination for Dalit Christians goes so far as to restrict not only employment but in some cases for clean sanitation and water.<ref>Jose, Kananaikil. 1990. [‘Scheduled Castes Converts and Social Disabilities: A Survey of Tamil Nadu’]</ref> Inter caste marriage among Christians is also not commonly practiced. For example, Syrian Christians in Kerala do not marry Dalit Christians. Even intermarriage between Bamons and Sudras in Goa is quite uncommon. Sometimes marriage to a higher class Hindu is preferred to marriage to a Dalit Christian. Discrimination against Dalit Christians also remained in interactions and mannerisms between castes for example, during the earlier days the ‘lower caste Christians’ had to close their mouth when talking to a Syrian Christian.<ref name="Dalit Christians In India"/> Even after conversion segregation, restriction, hierarchy and graded ritual purity remained to some extent. Data shows that there is more discrimination and less class mobility among the people living in the rural areas, where incidents of caste discrimination is higher among people from all religious backgrounds .<ref name="Dalit Christians In India"/>

In many cases, the churches referred to the Dalits as ‘New Christians'. It is alleged to be a derogatory term which classifies the Dalit Christians to be looked down upon by other Christians. During the earlier days of Christianity, in some churches in south India the Dalits had either separate seating or had to attend the mass from outside.<ref>Louis, Prakash. 2007.[ ‘Caste-based Discrimination and Atrocities on Dalit Christians and the Need for Reservations’, Working Paper Series, II(04): New Delhi: Indian Institute of Dalit Studies.]</ref> Dalit Christians are also said to be grossly underrepresented amongst the clergy in some places.<ref>[Indian Dalits find no refuge from caste in Christianity] BBC, sept 14 2010</ref>

==See also==
*[[Christianity in India]]
*[[Caste system among Muslims]]
*[[Dalit theology]]

==References==
{{Reflist}}

===Sources===
*Azariah M. ''The Un-Christian Side of the Indian Church''. Alit Sahitya Academy, 1985.
* {{Cite book
| last = Kenneth
| first = Ballhatchet
| title = Caste, Class and Catholicism in India, 1789–1914
| url = https://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN0700710957&printsec=frontcover
| accessdate = 2007-04-24
| year = 1998
| publisher = Routledge
| isbn = 0-7007-1095-7
}}
*Fuller, C.J.''Indian Christians: Pollution and Origins.'' ''Man'', New Series, Vol. 12, No. 3/4. (Dec., 1977)
*Henderson, Carol. ''Culture and Customs of India''. Greenwood Press, 2002.
*Koshy, Ninan. ''Caste in the Kerala Churches''. Bangalore: Christian Institute for the Study of Religion and Society, 1968.
*Manickam, Sundararaj. ''Studies in Missionary History: Reflections on a Culture-contact''. Christian Literature Society, 1988.
*Radhakrishnan, P.<u> Perfidies of Power: India in the New Millennium</u>. TR Publications, 2005.
*Michael, S.M.''Untouchable: Dalits in Modern India''. Lynne Riener Publishers, 1999. {{ISBN|1-55587-697-8}}
*Webster, John. ''The Christian Dalits: A History''. Delhi: Indian Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge (ISPCK), 1994.

==External links==
* [http://www.kamat.com/kalranga/people/pioneers/nobili.htm Roman Catholic Brahmin]
* [http://indianhope.free.fr/site_eng/article_5.php3 Discrimination against Untouchables by Christians]

{{DEFAULTSORT:Caste System Among Indian Christians}}
[[Category:Caste system in India|Christianity]]
[[Category:Christianity in India]]

Caste system among South Asian Christians - Revision history

KeishaBadham8: updated details

>Lembit Staan: /* Kerala */ an example how to carry out editing disputes without revert war; see the talk page now