ImportMaster: robot: Import pages from notability guidelines

2021-09-03T16:09:28Z

robot: Import pages from notability guidelines

New page

{{short description|Bharatpedia policy for notability of web pages}}
{{dablink|[[BP:WEB]] redirects here. You might be looking for [[Bharatpedia:Build the web]], [[Bharatpedia:WikiProject Websites]], [[Bharatpedia:WikiProject Internet]], [[Bharatpedia:WikiProject Blogging]], or [[Bharatpedia:WikiProject Internet culture]].}}
{{Bharatpedia subcat guideline|notability guideline|Websites|BP:WEB|BP:NWEB|BP:WEBPAGE|BP:WEBSITE|BP:WEBNOTE}}
{{nutshell|Bharatpedia should avoid articles about web sites that could be interpreted as [[BP:SPAM|advertising]]. For material published on the web to have its own article in Bharatpedia, it should be [[BP:N|notable]] and of [[BP:RECENTISM|historical significance]]. Bharatpedia articles about web content should use citations from [[BP:V|reliable sources]].}}
{{IncGuide}}

From {{section link|BP:NOT|INTERNET}}:
{{quote|'''Internet guides.''' Bharatpedia articles should not exist '''''only''''' to describe the nature, appearance or services a website offers, but should also describe the site in an ''encyclopedic manner'', offering detail on a website's achievements, impact or historical significance, which can be kept significantly more up-to-date than most reference sources, since editors can incorporate new developments and facts as they are made known. See the [[Portal:Current events|Current events portal]] for examples.}}

This page gives some rough guidelines which most Bharatpedia editors use to decide if a form of web-specific content, being either the content of a website or the specific website itself, should have an article on Bharatpedia. Web content includes, but is not limited to, [[blog]]s, [[Internet forum]]s, [[newsgroup]]s, [[online magazine]]s, other [[mass media|media]], [[Podcasting|podcasts]], [[webcomic]]s, and [[web portal|web portals]]. Any content accessed via the internet and engaged with primarily through a web browser is considered web content for the purposes of this guideline.<ref>Content distributed primarily through the web which does not fall under this definition should be considered a product, for which see [[Bharatpedia:Notability (companies and corporations)]].</ref>

Bharatpedians are averse to the use of Bharatpedia for [[Bharatpedia:Spam|advertising]], and the idea that [[Bharatpedia:What_Bharatpedia_is_not#Bharatpedia_is_not_a_soapbox|Bharatpedia articles are not advertisements]] is an official policy of long standing. Advertising is either [[Bharatpedia:cleanup|cleaned up]] to adhere to the [[Bharatpedia:neutral point of view|neutral point of view]] or deleted.<ref>Articles about websites or content which fail these guidelines but are related to a topic or subject which ''does'' merit inclusion may be [[Bharatpedia:Redirect|redirected]] to that topic or subject rather than be listed for deletion.</ref>

Bharatpedia is not a [[web directory]], in that it is not a site ''that specializes in linking to other web sites and categorizing those links.'' Bharatpedia is not a mirror or a repository of links, images, or media files. Articles which merely include an external link and a brief description of its contents may be deleted.

Topics that do not satisfy notability criteria are dealt with in two ways: [[Bharatpedia:Merge|merging]] and [[Bharatpedia:Deletion policy|deleting]]. Articles that may be non-notable can be marked with the {{tl|notability}} template to make other editors aware of the problem. When such articles are being listed for deletion, the articles are discussed at [[Bharatpedia:Articles for deletion]]. Alternatively, the [[BP:PROD|proposed deletion process]] may be used for articles that are ''uncontroversially'' deletion candidates, while the {{tl|db-web}} template can be used to mark an article for [[Bharatpedia:Criteria for speedy deletion|speedy deletion]]; see [[BP:A7|criterion A7]] for details.

==Decisions based on verifiable evidence==
{{Main|Bharatpedia:Notability#Notability requires verifiable evidence}}

In the dictionary, ''notable'' means "worthy of being noted" or "attracting notice." Bharatpedia bases its decision about whether web content is notable enough to justify a separate article on the verifiable evidence that the web content has attracted the notice of [[BP:RS|reliable sources]] ''unrelated'' to the web content, its authors, or its owners. Notability requires only that these necessary sources ''exist'', not that the sources have already been named in the article.

===No inherent notability===
{{Shortcut|BP:INHERENTWEB}}
"Notability" is not synonymous with "fame" or "importance," and even web content that editors personally believe is "important" or "famous" is only accepted as notable if it can be shown to have attracted notice. [[BP:ITSA|No web content is exempt from this requirement, no matter what kind of content it is]]. If the individual web content has received no or very little attention from [[BP:Independent sources|independent sources]], then it is not notable simply because other web content of its type is commonly notable or merely because [[BP:ENN|it exists]] (see [[#If the content is not notable|"If the content is not notable"]], below).

When evaluating the notability of web content, please consider whether it has had any significant or demonstrable effects on culture, society, entertainment, athletics, economies, history, literature, science, or education. High-traffic websites are likely to have more readily available [[BP:V|verifiable]] information from [[BP:RS|reliable sources]] that provide evidence of notability. However, smaller websites can also be notable. Arbitrary standards should not be used to create a bias favoring larger websites.

===No inherited notability===
{{Shortcut|BP:INHERITWEB}}
Web content is not notable merely because a notable person, business, or event was associated with it. If the web content itself did not receive notice, then the web content is not notable. For example, if a notable person has a website, then the website does not "inherit" notability from its owner. In such cases, it is often best to describe the website in the article about the notable person.

Similarly, a website may be notable, but the owners or authors do not "inherit" notability due to the web content they wrote.

== Criteria ==
{{Shortcut|BP:WEBCRIT}}
Keeping in mind that all articles must conform with [[Bharatpedia:Verifiability|the policy on verifiability]] to [[Bharatpedia:Reliable sources|reliable sources]], and that non-independent and self-published sources alone are not sufficient to establish notability; web-specific content<ref>Discussions of websites should be incorporated (with a redirect if necessary) into an article about the parent organization, unless the domain-name of the website is the most common way of referring to the organization. For example, [[yahoo.com]] is a redirect to [[Yahoo!]]. On the other hand [[Drugstore.com]] is a standalone page.</ref> may be notable based on meeting one of the following criteria:
*The content itself has been the subject of multiple non-trivial published works whose source is independent of the site itself. This criterion includes [[BP:RS|reliable]] published works in all forms, such as newspaper articles, magazine articles, books, television documentaries, websites, and published reports by consumer watchdog organizations<ref>Examples:
* The webcomic ''[[When I Am King]]'' has been reviewed by ''[[The Guardian]]'', ''[[Playboy (magazine)|Playboy]]'', ''[[The Comics Journal]]'', and ''[[Wired magazine|Wired]]''.
* The blog [[Daily Kos]] has been covered by ''[[Los Angeles Times]]'', ''[[Time (magazine)|Time]]'', ''[[The Washington Post]]'', ''[[U.S. News & World Report]]'', and ''[[The New York Times]]''.</ref> ''except'' for media re-prints of press releases and advertising for the content or site<ref>Self-promotion and product placement are not the routes to having an encyclopedia article. The published works must be by ''someone else'' who is writing about the company, corporation, product, or service. (See [[Bharatpedia:Autobiography]] for the verifiability and neutrality problems that arise in material where the subject of the article itself is the source of material cited in the article.) The barometer of notability is whether people ''independent'' of the subject itself (or of its manufacturer, creator, or vendor) have actually considered the content or site worthy enough that they have written and published non-trivial works that focus upon it.</ref> or trivial coverage, such as a brief summary of the nature of the content or the publication of Internet addresses and site, newspaper articles that simply report the times at which such content is updated or made available, or the content descriptions in directories or [[online store]]s.
*The website or content has won a well-known and independent award from either a publication or organization. Ideally, this award itself is also notable and already has a Bharatpedia article.<ref>Being nominated for such an award in multiple years ''may'' also be considered an indicator of notability.</ref>
These criteria are presented as [[rules of thumb]] for easily identifying web content about which Bharatpedia should probably have an article. In almost all cases, a thorough search for [[Bharatpedia:Independent sources|independent, third-party reliable sources]] will be successful for content meeting one or both of these criteria. However, meeting these criteria is not a guarantee that Bharatpedia will host a separate, stand-alone article on the website.

==If the content is not notable==
{{Further|BP:FAILN}}

Bharatpedia should not have a separate article on any web content that does not meet the criteria of either this guideline or the general notability guideline, or any web content that, despite meeting the rules of thumb described above, for whom editors ultimately cannot locate [[Bharatpedia:Independent sources|independent sources]] that provide in-depth information about the web content. Bharatpedia's goal is neither [[BP:PERMASTUB|tiny articles with no realistic hope of expansion]] nor articles based primarily on what the subject or its creators say about themselves.

However, information about such web content may nevertheless be included in other ways in Bharatpedia, provided that certain conditions are met. Material about web content that does not qualify for a separate, stand-alone can be [[BP:PRESERVE|preserved]] by adding it into relevant articles if it:
* has the [[BP:DUE|appropriate level]] of detail and significance for that article;
* [[BP:NOTPROMOTION|avoids self-promotion]]; and
* includes information that can be [[Bharatpedia:Verfiability|verified]] through [[BP:Independent sources|independent sources]].

Web content that does not qualify for a separate, stand-alone article might be described in a relevant list of web content like the [[List of internet phenomena]]. Material about websites might be merged to articles about the organizations that own the websites. Appropriate redirects from the subject's name should be created to help readers find such information.

== See also ==
* [[Bharatpedia:Cite sources]]
* [[Bharatpedia:Neutral point of view]]
* [[Bharatpedia:No original research]]
* [[Bharatpedia:Reliable sources]]
* [[Bharatpedia:Search engine test]]
* [[Bharatpedia:Verifiability]]

== Notes ==


{{Reflist|30em}}

Bharatpedia:Notability (web) - Revision history

ImportMaster: robot: Import pages from notability guidelines